PSA review results

[Touch'EmAll]

I sent an item to PSA thinking it was a lock for an "8", it came back a PSA "6".

Immediately returned this item to PSA for review, told them absolutely not a PSA 6, but rather a minimum PSA 8. I wrote PSA that they must have made a simple mistake and please take a second good look.

Grades posted - is now a PSA 8.

Question: Do I have to eat all grading review costs and shipping costs just to get my item regraded correctly the second time - when it was their mistake and should have been properly graded the initial time?

And what do you all think about such a drastic PSA original mis-grade (by 2 full grades - WOW!)?

edited - would rather not divulge what the specific item was.

[Ladder7]

Dont stop now... Send it back again with another check!

[Jim VB]

Originally Posted by Ladder7

Dont stop now... Send it back again with another check!

Steve's right. This time tell them it's a minimum PSA 11!

[Peter_Spaeth]

It's only one card, and it's an imperfect world.

Another reason I stay away from PSA.

I guess I should send my Johnson to them and ask for a 9. That way it's worth more money

I am endlessly amazed by the industry everyday.

[glynparson]

It is a cost of doing business. If you call them before your item ships you can often get a free rerview. This generally works for either PSA or SGC in my experience.