Comiskey Help

[rschisler]

Hi guys, was looking at adding this Comiskey signature to the collection and wanted your opinions if I may, as I trust you far more than PSA quick opinion. It’s not one of his common signature styles, but I did find some similarities to this style elsewhere. Thanks in advance!

[tazdmb]

I have seen TPAs pass these signature types, but I believe this is secretarial.

[rschisler]

Thanks for your input, Taz. I wondered about that myself. I found this example that went on heritage pre-certified by PSA. Seems to be a match and around the same time period but other examples don’t seem to line up.

[ThomasL]

I believe both of those are secretarial and signed by Harry Grabiner the White Sox team secretary...just my opinion

[ThomasL]

Grabiner is who filled out the White Sox contracts and here is an example from Lefty Williams 1920 contract where you can see some of the same letters used

[rschisler]

Originally Posted by ThomasL

Grabiner is who filled out the White Sox contracts and here is an example from Lefty Williams 1920 contract where you can see some of the same letters used

Thanks, Thomas. Great info and thanks for including the contract piece. I'll have to watch out for those in the future.