Another PSA mess up? major card - AA to 5

[Rhotchkiss]

This was posted on another site I visit (not blowout)- sorry to have to do this via pics. SuperDan from BODA believes that a PSA Altered, t206 Red Cobb, Carolina Brights, now sits in a PSA 5 flip.

You all decide. To all PSA apologists, this is not mere PSA-hating: even if there was no foul play, there is simply no excuse for a card of this caliber to go from an AA flip to a 5, period. I am fairly sure it is, or was until recently, part of the David Hall collection, which if true, does not look good either.

I would hate to be the guy who spent all that money for a card these experts once determined was altered....

“Never get Cheated”

[luciobar1980]

Thos epics are very very low quality. Can you link us to original images?

[yanks12025]

Can you please post better photos

[biggsdaddycool]

Yes, please...better pics.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Rhotchkiss]

Lets see if these are better. I will link the site/thread if I am permitted to do so.

[Pat R]

Technically David Hall still owns it. He purchased it in the PSA 5 holder and it
hasn't come up for sale in one of his auctions yet.

[dabbuu]

Wow, cut and dry same card. Thank you for posting

[mantlefan]

That's a match Ryan. There are several small spots on the top border which are the same on both images. Thanks for posting,

[atx840]

Prior to the Altered -

[Wanaselja]

Originally Posted by mantlefan

That's a match Ryan. There are several small spots on the top border which are the same on both images. Thanks for posting,

Agreed. Clearest indicators.

[Rhotchkiss]

Originally Posted by Pat R

Technically David Hall still owns it. He purchased it in the PSA 5 holder and it
hasn't come up for sale in one of his auctions yet.

Pat, I think this card may been purchased from the David Hall collection privately before the auctions began.