1910 Cleveland Naps Team panorama question

[Angyale]

I picked this up at the 2014 National from a NY dealer. Its 5” tall by 17” wide and on thick paper/thin cardboard with a blank back. It appears to consist of thick ink with no dot pattern. Maybe a lithograph? The new League Park opened in 1910 so I thought it might have been a giveaway for that occassion or it might have been an insert in a paper. However, Elmer Flick isnt in the photo so it rules out the early season roster. The photographer, Haines, is from Conneaut, Ohio. Ive seen this photo online, but not in the same format and composition. Any help would be appreciated. Any idea where/how/when it was distributed?

Thanks, Angyale

[Hankphenom]

I've seen a colorized Cleveland panorama with Jackson that was a newspaper insert, but can't say if that was the same image as this one. I'm not liking the color of this one, a similar yellowing found on a generation of fakes/repros from a few years ago.

[Angyale]

Hank,

I bought it in 2014. Seller at National in 2014 got it from an auction house lot. Not sure if it was Leelands, Heritage, or whichever, and I sure wish I saved the provenance info. There is a 1910 panorama of the exact same photo on Christie’s website that sold for over $6k in 2016. Mine is much smaller. I’m going to do a deep dive into the archives of whatever auction houses I can find online.

Angyale

[Angyale]

It in the September 1, 2013 Mears Online Auction. Lot #249. It’s my exact item. Is Mears knowledgeable with regard to prewar photographic items? Hank, the colorized panorama you are referring to was a supplement to a Cleveland paper from somewhere between 1911 and 1913 as I recall.

Angyale

[Leon]

What does it say in that lower right hand corner? Looks like a supplement...but maybe not.
.

[Hankphenom]

Originally Posted by Leon

What does it say in that lower right hand corner? Looks like a supplement...but maybe not..

If it is period, about which I have my doubts, it's most certainly a supplement or insert of some kind; there's nothing about it that resembles an original type 1 photo.