FS: 1887 N172 Old Judge HOF

[BPorter26]

I've decided to sell my 1887 Old Judge cards both cards are HOFers. I'm not sure what to offer for pricing since these are POP 1's but will take offers. I also have them listed on eBay as my seller's name is jackiemoonaba33.

Thanks
Bobby


Billy Hamilton - PSA 1 (POP 1) none higher **SOLD**




Tommy McCarthy PSA 1MK (POP 1) with 2 higher

[Schwertfeger1007]

FYI

SGC has graded 29 Hamiltons and 68 McCarthys

Plenty of comps out there.

[BPorter26]

Originally Posted by Schwertfeger1007

FYI

SGC has graded 29 Hamiltons and 68 McCarthys

Plenty of comps out there.

Not sure how you came up with these number. I went on SGC website, and these were the results. There's been no sales on these cards since 2013 & 2017 in a PSA holder.

Hamilton POP 9 and only 1 with the card I have for sale. Hamilton has 6 variations.


McCarthy POP 20 and only 3 W/ St.Louis that I have for sale. McCarthy has 9 variations.

[bandrus1]

So what did Hamilton sell for

[Schwertfeger1007]

Why does it matter if it is a PSA sale vs SGC...especially in lower graded / altered cards?

SGC only recently started designating poses so specific pose pop #'s are meaningless.

Hamilton only has 5 poses (not 6) and none command a premium over any others.

I was giving you the benefit of the doubt that you were sincerely trying to find comps (vs trying to make these sound more special then they actually are) my mistake