favorite prewar players to collect?

[Archive]

Posted By: Ben

For me, I have a particular fondness for HOF pitchers. In no particular order, here are my favorite players to collect:

-Waddell and Plank (they really doesnt appear on too many cards do they!)
-Mordecai Brown
-Addie Joss (love his t205)
-Johnson and Young and Matty (of course)
-Keeler

I know we all have our preferences- so let them be known!

[Archive]

Posted By: Ben

Please excuse my appalling grammar in the above post...Plank and Waddell really DONT appear on too many cards do they!

[Archive]

Posted By: Jeff S

...

[Archive]

Posted By: jay behrens

Favortie pre-WW2 players:

Sam Crawford
Ken Williams
Benny Kauff
Lou Sockalexis
Guy Hecker
Rogers Hornsby


Jay

[Archive]

Posted By: Bob D

which war?

pre WW II - Ruth, no one comes close

pre WW I - I could say Ruth again, but I know I'll never collect any of his pre-WW I cards, so I'll go with Walter Johnson.

[Archive]

Posted By: Anonymous

Chalk up another vote for Sockalexis. Hey- maybe we should change this thread to "great baseball names"!!!!

[Archive]

Posted By: John(z28jd)

Tom Reilly,i have triples of every card he has.Take that Bill Cornell!

[Archive]

Posted By: Jay Miller

Keeler-Collect em where they ain't

[Archive]

Posted By: mrc32

As my post last week on "Player checklists" indicated, I am collecting Wilbur Good(e). Why? Well without owning his T-205 card and having it stare at me for all these years, I would never have started the T-205 set and never would have ventured to read and learn about the Deadball era. It has been quite a wonderful and enlightenting history lesson.

PS- I have 2 of his cards (as I really just started with the player collection) so if anyone has any email me!

[Archive]

Posted By: three25hits

... Paul Strand. I have his Obak and three Zee Nut cards, but always looking for better examples.

Also trying to collect photo's, media reports, and information about his career and life.

Please email if you have any info (NWL, PCL buffs etc.)

Thanks

[Archive]

Posted By: Mike (18colt)

. . . Hugh Duffy and Hal Chase. T-206 cards of each got me started (the blue background portrait for Chase).

If anyone has a low, low, low, low, low grade Duffy from any of his 19th century issues, please let me know ("good" is too nice -- fair or poor for me, the uglier the better).

[Archive]

Posted By: Mike (18colt)

Sorry, I forgot some info. I would rather trade for a Duffy as mentioned in my prior post. And e-mail me by clicking on my name above (I forgot to include earlier).

[Archive]

Posted By: Adam J. Baxter

There are tons of 19th century players I like, but to save some space I'll have to include only a few:

Harry Stovey
Charlie Buffinton
Marty Bergen
Fred Klobedanz
Nat Hudson

to name just a few..

Also:

Ty Cobb
Rube Waddell
Hughie Jennings
Rogers Hornsby
Charlie Gehringer
Tris Speaker
Joe Wood
Lefty Grove


My all-time favorite from any era is:

Leroy "Satchel" Paige

[Archive]

Posted By: mrc32

Adam-
I have a autographed business card of "Ole Satch," from when he worked for the Springfield Redbirds in the 1980s. My dad actually met him.

That card is one of my favorite pieces of memorabilia.

[Archive]

Posted By: warshawlaw

I have no idea why, either. Maybe because I lived in SF for a time and visited what had been his bar regularly. Maybe I've just got a soft spot in my heart for a guy who was so positive for baseball for so many years and so damned good. Whatever, I'm hooked on Lefty's stuff. I've got a Tattoo Orbit, a 1927 Zeenuts, a 1925-1929 PC back Exhibit, both 1933 Goudeys. Anyone with others of Lefty, drop me a line.

Another favorite before WII (I assume that's the war you meant?) is Buddy Myer (1933 Goudey, 1933 National Chicle autographed, 1936 Goudey Wide Pen, 1939 Goudey).

Lefty Grove and Jimmy Foxx too. I always think of them together. Grove fascinates me because he did what are arguably the two most important things better than anyone in history: (1) win and (2) not allow opponents to score. Had he not been in Baltimore for years, I think he would easily have reached 400-425 victories. Foxx started out as a collecting interest only because it took me years to find a reasonable card of his to buy when I was first collecting (ca. 1975-1980). Back then, especially at the start and on the east coast, Foxx was right up with Gehrig price-wise on many issues. Boy, has that gap expanded as 500 HR's becomes a commonplace event. Now that I can afford his cards, I buy them regularly.

The Big Train is another favorite of mine. Three exhibits and the T206's to show for it. A true gentleman.

Hack Wilson is interesting too. My favorite 1933 Goudey is his. Just got the 1928 Exhibit. Tough to find, so I was pretty stoked.

I also really like Zeenuts cards of HOFers and other notables. Again, don't know why, exactly; something quaint about these minor leaguers who became alltime greats or who were trying to hang in there after their primes. Some day, Joltin' Joe, your card will be mine!

Now, post-WWII, I collect an eclectic list (in no particular order): Sandy Koufax, Shawn Green, Hank Aaron, Ted Williams, 1970's Yankees (esp. Thurman Munson, Willie Randolph, Ron Guidry, Graig Nettles), Mike Lieberthal, Gabe Kapler, Ken Holtzman, Don Drysdale, 1950's Yankees pichers.

[Archive]

Posted By: TBob

Matty
Bucky Weaver
Nap Lajoie
Eddie Cicotte
Ten Million

[Archive]

Posted By: brian p

Here are some of the players I have had a little extra interest in over the years:

Christy Mathewson
Wally Berger
Heinie Groh

[Archive]

Posted By: Albie O'Hanian

Pre World War II

Ruth
Gehrig
Williams
Feller
Dean

[Archive]

Posted By: scott brockelman

buck weaver & jesse burkett.

[Archive]

Posted By: JC

Joe Jackson
Joe Dimaggio
Cy Young
Harry Wright
Tim Keefe

[Archive]

Posted By: runscott

The shinier the card, the better...oh, wait a minute - last time I checked vintage card collectors didn't collect stuff like that...then I'll go with Nap Rucker and Ed Reulbach.

[Archive]

Posted By: ty_cobb

I like all the 'rebels' who played West Coast ball,
Chick Gandil (have the T206 Red Hindu and a NM T213)
and Hal Chase (have a T206 Lennox back w. Trophy).
Bev on the old forum got me into the Cubbies, she
sent me this huge scan of a baseball theme stained
glass window she had from (I think) Johnny Kling's
Billiards Hall. I used to have some of the Cubbies contracts and other letters from management, especially regarding the contract holdout (circa 1909 I believe).
Some of the Cubbies played interleague, I like
Johnny Kling, Joe Tinker, and Johnny Evers. Kling was
especially sucessful in establishing America's first
integrated ballpark (KC Monarchs I beleive).

[Archive]

Posted By: JC

What other 2 player combo's from any decade, will have better numbers than A-Rod and Vlady when their careers are thru? BTW where are all the Vlady West Palm Beach cards from 1996?

[Archive]

Posted By: Julie

Kelly ( 6 different)
Radbourne ( 5 different)
Keefe ( 3 different)
Ewing ( 6 different)
Sam Thompson (2)
Nicholl (Only the Mayo--damn.)
Ned Hanlon (Scrapps and--oh GREAT Fan Craze!)
Fleet Walker (The one photo)
Dummy Hoy (2 different)
Brouthers (3 different)
Caruthers (3 different)
O'Neill (2 different)

I WAS going to get one of each 19th century HOFer--you can see why my progress has been somewhat limited.

20th century:

Joss (3)
Keeler (2)
Mordicai Brown (5)
Buck Weaver and Joe Jackson and Cicotte and lefty Williams (too many to count, photos and cards)
Kennesaw Mountain Landis (Conlon photo)
Kid Gleason (Allegheny, Conlon photo--my favorite Conlon--and one more (trimmed)
Ruth (4)
Lajoie (5)
Cobb (6--most are T202s)
Johnson (3)
Matty (6--Most are T202s)
Bored?

2 Paiges, a whole bunch of J. Robinsons, Koufax (his '60s cards are gorgeous, plus a photo--smiling)
4 Greenbergs (but no rookie!), Nagashima (4) Oh (too many...)Nomura (greatest japanese catcher- hit over 600 home runs)ichiro Suzuki (2--Japanese cards)
Jeter's Pinnacle rookie; Puckett's '84 and '85 Fleer.
Early autographed photo, and engraving of Ricky Henderson
I think I may have overstepped the bounds of hospitality Ben Fisher extended when he started this thread...

[Archive]

Posted By: jay behrens

We talking any 10 year stretch? And what stats? I think Ruth and Hornsby from 1920-1929 would be very hard to beat. And Hornsby's 1921-5 seasons are easily the greatest 5 year run ever put on by a hitter.

Jay

[Archive]

Posted By: Anonymous

"What other 2 player combo's from any decade, will have better numbers than A-Rod and Vlady when their careers are thru?"


Ted Williams and Stan Musial. Willie Mays and Mickey Mantle.

Or for modern comparison -- Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera.

Probably not many more though.

[Archive]

Posted By: three25hits

apologies

[Archive]

Posted By: Rhett

Roy Castleton, he has a bunch of PCL items, played for the Reds for a stint. He was the first Mormon to ever play pro ball.

[Archive]

Posted By: Julie

The 1869 Cincinatti Redstockings.
Peck and Snyder's droopy-lipped man on the back of above.