moral question

[bbcard1]

I'm just about to finish off a hostess set (1976) all in panels. I'm thinking I would enjoy them more as a set for cards so I could put them in individual toploads...to cut or not to cut? how much is the value premium really?

Sorry, I know it's not vintage, but I'll bet a lot of folks have similar questions on strips.

[sayhey24]

I don't think there's any question at all -- keep them the way they came -- in uncut panels!

Greg
http://www.baseballbasement.com

[Danny Smith]

Keep em the way they are

[cardaholic]

and build another set of the individual cards.

[joeadcock]

DO not cut them up

[E93]

Keep them uncut!
JimB

[bbcard1]

Originally Posted by sayhey24

I don't think there's any question at all -- keep them the way they came -- in uncut panels!

Greg
http://www.baseballbasement.com

Greg, just to be official, I could have never kept them the way they came because the came with TWINKIES!

[vargha]

Leave them as panels. Man, I can't believe how many Twinkies, Ding Dongs and Ho Ho's I ate as a kid, getting those cards.

[tothrk]

I don't know anything about this issue but even if these are plentiful & readily available as panels, I say leave them as panels.

[drc]

I would chose to keep them as panels, but don't consider it a moral or ethical question.

If this is your biggest moral dilemma, you're probably going to Heaven.

[Griffins]

Order a box of 3 pocket pages, and put the intact panels in the pages.

[E93]

If you want individual cards in toploaders, sell this set and buy ones that are already cut.
JimB

[obcmac]

They were meant to be cut...you must help them fulfill their destiny.

Mac

[E93]

Originally Posted by obcmac

They were meant to be cut...you must help them fulfill their destiny.

Mac

Should we chop up all uncut sheets that still remain in the hobby too?
JimB

[obcbobd]

For me, if it's the entire box bottom I'd keep as is. But if its already been cut to a panel of just the three cards, then I say finish the job and cut em.

[4815162342]

Here's another vote for DON'T CUT!

[David W]

just put together another set already cut up.

[novakjr]

Cutting up the panels is somewhat of a disturbing idea to me...I'd say, sell the complete panel set, and put together a set of singles. You'd probably make a few bucks in the process.

[camlov2]

Originally Posted by obcbobd

For me, if it's the entire box bottom I'd keep as is. But if its already been cut to a panel of just the three cards, then I say finish the job and cut em.

I believe the cards were on the side of the box and were only a strip of three to start with.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by obcmac

They were meant to be cut...you must help them fulfill their destiny.

Mac

That made me laugh out loud.

But, my vote is that you do not cut them.

Doug

[steve B]

Originally Posted by camlov2

I believe the cards were on the side of the box and were only a strip of three to start with.

Nope, on the bottom, with info usually above and below. Most boxes were strips of three. The exceptions are the small boxes- yodels? That didn't have room for anything other than the cards, and cupcakes which had an irregular panel of 3. They also came in the cupacke and twinkie 2 packs as single cards with either a little panel above and below-cupcakes. Or a more square panel, thecard with 3 really wide borders. There are back diferences between them too.

Personally I'd leave the panels as panels, and find a nice set of singles. Like others have said you'll probably end up with a bit of extra hobby money too.

I've considered trying for a set of complete boxes, but it takes up a load of room. So I've got the whole assortment.

Steve B

[ls7plus]

My vote is absolutely do not cut them up--they're like a collector car, that's only original once!!!

Larry

[CubsFanCurt]

Keep them uncut!