most overrated player and pitcher

[Archive]

Posted By: Scott Forrest

"over-rated" and "under-rated" can't be measured using stats as you just tried to do - it's simply not what these two terms mean ("evaluated too low" and "evaluated too high").

You can make such measurements if you want, of course, and I'm sure they have value, but you'll have to define the results using different terms (perhaps "above average" and "below average" would do).