PSA-not graded due to miscut

[Archive]

Posted By: George Leidemer

Hello, first posts, happy collecting. been submitting to PSA for the past 4 years and got a submission back today. Never fight with them about grades but this issue really ticks me off. Submitted a 1928 Yuengling's Ice Cream Cobb in the EX range which if I am correct and pulled a PSA 5 tonight would have been their highest on the pop report, not sure if sgc has graded one higher. Logged in to my account and it came back N8: MISCUT. Spoke to a manager and they confirmed no alteration(she stated this would have been noted), also stated it wasnt undersized or it would be noted minimum size requirement. This has happened twice in 4 years and ended up eventually sending to sgc, (remember my T206 bender 4 in one piedmont miscut being one of the other times) and sgc slabbed both with no problems. Please help, why do some t206's i have get an MC qualifier or the jumbo wagner that sold recently, and some get returned unslabbed. george