Another set with year misidentified by both PSA and SGC

[Leon]

Hey Brian
Our friends at OldCardboard.com are on top of it.

1923 V89 Wm. Paterson

Year(s) Published: 1923
ACC Designation: V89
Set Name: William Paterson
Card Size (inches): 2 x 3-1/4
Number of Cards in Set: 50
Est. Value (common; VG): $70

Produced by Wm. Paterson, Limited of Brantford, Canada
Numbered set of 50 with wide white border and blank backs
Found in both sepia and black and white printings
Card number, player and team printed at bottom
Date of issue not certain; some checklists say 1922"

Originally Posted by brianp-beme

Like my thread on W503, the V89 is another set that the year is likely misidentified by both PSA and SGC as a 1922 instead of 1923 issue. I did not research fully like I did for the W503 set, but as I was checking out Herb Pennock for W503 I came across the image of his V89 card, which he is identified as being a New York Yankee, just like he is on his W530 card. Pennock was traded from the Red Sox to the Yankees on January 30, 1923, and thus this set should at least be identified as a 1923 issue (for example as 1922-23), or perhaps if someone were to do more research they could narrow it down to just 1923 instead...I am currently tired.

Brian (card not mine, tiredness all mine)