Is it just me or do these seem undergraded ???

[Joshchisox08]

I used to think SGC was the more consistent of the grading companies but these couple leave me scratching my head.

Thoughts ?

Just added Danny Murphy MC ??? Trimmed ??? If so not sure why it got a numerical grade or even past a 10/1

[iwantitiwinit]

Devlin looks to have a small amount of paper loss on the back above the word "series". If it does no matter how small it's an incomplete card and deserves no more than a three in my opinion despite a nice front.

[Joshchisox08]

Originally Posted by iwantitiwinit

Devlin looks to have a small amount of paper loss on the back above the word "series". If it does no matter how small it's an incomplete card and deserves no more than a three in my opinion despite a nice front.

That's a valid point however it's microscopic portions of the card lol.

[Stetson_1883]

Scott looks at least like a 3.5. Delvin's a 4.

I just purchased this "4" tonight

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by Joshchisox08

That's a valid point however it's microscopic portions of the card lol.

SGC will only give a 3 at best with paper loss. I had a NrMint Babe Ruth that I bought from a fellow board member that had a speck of paper loss on the right border and it got a 3.

[Pat R]

The Scott could be a high 3 or low 4 I agree with Robert on the Devlin because of the paper loss.

[Luke]

If I sent those in I'd be hoping for a 4 on Devlin and a 3.5 on Scott. Nice cards no matter what the slip of paper says!

[swarmee]

The Hoffman has a big '44' written in blue crayon on the back. That could be the reason for the downgrade.

[kmac32]

Maybe on the Devlin SGC 40 but otherwise spot on.

[pokerplyr80]

Each card seems to have an issue that justifies the grade. I think all three are about right.

[glynparson]

absolutely look correctly graded. They have nice eye appeal for their grades but all have issues some fairly serious which dictates their grades. I could honestly see the Devlin getting a lower grade before i could see any of the others grading higher. I wouldn't drop over if i sent the Devlin in and got a 30 or 35.

[Joshchisox08]

Originally Posted by glynparson

absolutely look correctly graded. They have nice eye appeal for their grades but all have issues some fairly serious which dictates their grades. I could honestly see the Devlin getting a lower grade before i could see any of the others grading higher. I wouldn't drop over if i sent the Devlin in and got a 30 or 35.

Just when I thought I had the lower grading down to scale haha. I guess I'm good at a 1-2.5 and not so good at 3 and above. Lots of homework to do. That's why I asked for everyone's help!!!

Thanks for the responsed.