T206 Wagner & Plank fake or real

[Taxman]

Do these Plank & Wagner look wrong? Both look artificially aged and cases look compromised?

[Taxman]

Guy has them posted on Facebook.

[Taxman]

Wagner back has factory 30

[Mountaineer1999]

Not sure about fake but i am sure if I owned them I would not advertise them on Facebook

[drcy]

How much is he advertising them for? That might answer your question.

If he doesn't show the entire card(s), it's should be an automatic pass. I can understand a small watermark, but cropping out large and important parts of the card should be enough for a buyer to simply pass.

[Taxman]

Not for sale just self gratification by saying they are his. Once I started asking questions about factory number of Wagner he deleted the post.
https://www.facebook.com/groups/PSACARDS/

[drcy]

Okay then. I agree with your original opinion.

[ajjohnsonsoxfan]

1000% fake

[Sean1125]

Based on the fact that he offered me a "rose 9" shortly after I sold one and I made him an obscene offer on it he instantly "had it sold" and "it was unavailable" then deleted and blocked me.

This guy is a complete fraud and does this to impress people who don't know any better. Facebook is... Well... This is why I stayed off facebook for pretty much my entire life.

[Taxman]

Well I've now been blocked for pointing out he was a fraud.

[TCMA]

I've seen those cards posted before. What group is he posting them in now?

[Taxman]

This is why he covers up the grade

[swarmee]

Not really; most likely fake flips in fake/cracked holders.

[Sean]

Originally Posted by swarmee

Not really; most likely fake flips in fake/cracked holders.

I think that he covers the cert#s because they're fake. If someone checked with PSA they wouldn't match.

[PolarBear]

[JustinD]

Um.

[Charlie Faust III]

I take a complete different approach to this thread and always give the benefit of doubt to the initiator of the thread, with all due respect.

First, I ask myself; what can I learn from pics of these two cards posted? To date, all known T206 Wagner and Planks that have been seen by us online collectors, I believe are documented. Are these two cards in that database? Not all collectors of T206 are on the internet so it is almost a certainty that there are more.

I once talked to an old guy that was 97 years old and just happened to ask him if he was on the internet? He asked me to repeat and so I did as I got closer to his ear. He then replied by saying; what? Can you repeat that again please son?

It was at that point that I knew that he had no clue what I was even talking about. I wasn't surprised because I was just passing through a small corn town in the middle of nowhere North Dakota. When I entered the town; the green and white sign said population 109 .He wasn't the oldest guy I saw in that little town. I just remembered that when I last saw a cell tower; it was at my previous gas stop five hours earlier in western North Dakota.

Take Care Charlie

[Leon]

Sometimes things that sound strange are just strange things. It happens.

btw, I would imagine most Wagners and Planks on FB and Craigslist aren't good, for one reason or another, but there is always that chance.

Originally Posted by Charlie Faust III

I take a complete different approach to this thread and always give the benefit of doubt to the initiator of the thread, with all due respect.

First, I ask myself; what can I learn from pics of these two cards posted? To date, all known T206 Wagner and Planks that have been seen by us online collectors, I believe are documented. Are these two cards in that database? Not all collectors of T206 are on the internet so it is almost a certainty that there are more.

I once talked to an old guy that was 97 years old and just happened to ask him if he was on the internet? He asked me to repeat and so I did as I got closer to his ear. He then replied by saying; what? Can you repeat that again please son?

It was at that point that I knew that he had no clue what I was even talking about. I wasn't surprised because I was just passing through a small corn town in the middle of nowhere North Dakota. When I entered the town; the green and white sign said population 109 .He wasn't the oldest guy I saw in that little town. I just remembered that when I last saw a cell tower; it was at my previous gas stop five hours earlier in western North Dakota.

Take Care Charlie