Does this look like a 5 to anyone...

[Eric72]

Originally Posted by irv

I did the same, but like, G1911, I also thought 3 at best but was leaning more towards a 2.5.
I don't know slabs hardly at all, but does the left, bottom left and full bottom not look frosted?

When looking at any graded card, I message the seller: "Is the PSA (or SGC, BVG, BGS) holder damaged in any way?"

I've gotten the entire spectrum of answers, from dead silence to detailed explanations. And yes, I've gotten a few nasty replies. It's kind of fascinating to read the answers, at times.

In any event, the answer serves two purposes:

1. Gives me an idea of the type of seller I would be dealing with, if I decide to purchase
2. Gives me an expanded "item description" - in case an INAD return is in order