Best players to manage in the major leagues

Peter_Spaeth · #1 10-12-2025, 12:44 PM

Pujols is probably the best example of how there can be a conflict between metrics and counting stats. Consider 2016 -- 31 HR, 119 RBI, WAR 1.5 Better yet, 2017 -- 23 HR, 101 RBI, WAR..... wait for it..... NEGATIVE 2.0.

I think with 700 HR and very little steroid noise Pujols' legacy will be very favorable despite his AL years being crummy by the metrics.

Mark17 · #2 10-12-2025, 12:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

Pujols is probably the best example of how there can be a conflict between metrics and counting stats. Consider 2016 -- 31 HR, 119 RBI, WAR 1.5 Better yet, 2017 -- 23 HR, 101 RBI, WAR..... wait for it..... NEGATIVE 2.0.

I think with 700 HR and very little steroid noise Pujols' legacy will be very favorable despite his AL years being crummy by the metrics.

Agree. But not above Wagner, Cobb, Walter, etc.

Peter_Spaeth · #3 10-12-2025, 12:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark17

Agree. But not above Wagner, Cobb, Walter, etc.

Agree, although we of a certain generation need to be mindful of our nostalgia bias.

rats60 · #4 10-12-2025, 08:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

Pujols is probably the best example of how there can be a conflict between metrics and counting stats. Consider 2016 -- 31 HR, 119 RBI, WAR 1.5 Better yet, 2017 -- 23 HR, 101 RBI, WAR..... wait for it..... NEGATIVE 2.0.

I think with 700 HR and very little steroid noise Pujols' legacy will be very favorable despite his AL years being crummy by the metrics.

There is no conflict. Pujols was the Angels DH those two years. His job was only to hit and he wasn't very good at it. In 2016 he had an OPS+ of 116. In 2017 he had an OPS+ of 80 that is why he had a negative WAR. If the Angels didn't owe him 140 million dollars, they would have released him and he would have been out of baseball.

Mark hit on the point I was making, Pujols was a good player, but not in the class of Wagner, Cobb, Johnson or Williams. Wagner had an 8.1 WAR season at age 38. Williams had a 9.7 WAR season at age 38. Cobb hit .378 with an OPS+ of 171 at age 38. Johnson won a pitching triple crown at age 36.

At age 37 Pujols was a full time DH with an OPS+ of 80 and WAR of minus 2. He would have OPS+ seasons of 91, 92, 79 and 66 before the Angels released in the final year of his contract. The next season when Pujols need to perform to get at bats, he was suddenly an OPS+ 153 hitter after coasting for a decade in Anaheim collecting 240 million dollars from the Angels.

Peter_Spaeth · #5 10-12-2025, 09:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rats60

There is no conflict. Pujols was the Angels DH those two years. His job was only to hit and he wasn't very good at it. In 2016 he had an OPS+ of 116. In 2017 he had an OPS+ of 80 that is why he had a negative WAR. If the Angels didn't owe him 140 million dollars, they would have released him and he would have been out of baseball.

Mark hit on the point I was making, Pujols was a good player, but not in the class of Wagner, Cobb, Johnson or Williams. Wagner had an 8.1 WAR season at age 38. Williams had a 9.7 WAR season at age 38. Cobb hit .378 with an OPS+ of 171 at age 38. Johnson won a pitching triple crown at age 36.

At age 37 Pujols was a full time DH with an OPS+ of 80 and WAR of minus 2. He would have OPS+ seasons of 91, 92, 79 and 66 before the Angels released in the final year of his contract. The next season when Pujols need to perform to get at bats, he was suddenly an OPS+ 153 hitter after coasting for a decade in Anaheim collecting 240 million dollars from the Angels.

I would agree that the metrics tell the real story but yes there's a conflict, because if you just look at the counting stats you might think he had a couple of pretty good seasons. I think we're saying the same thing just semantics. As we've discussed many times, the RBI totals are inflated because he was hitting behind a man with a truly scary on base percentage, Mike Trout.

All that said though, I think his legacy will be strong.

butchie_t · #6 10-12-2025, 09:44 PM

Frank Howard��Don�t care, he is my favorite player.

Butch

bk400 · #7 10-14-2025, 07:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by butchie_t

Frank Howard��Don�t care, he is my favorite player.

Butch

Is this the same Frank Howard that destroyed Mookie Wilson's shoulder by having the Mets practice throws with balls that had been waterlogged after a rainstorm?

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Switch to Linear Mode Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Who has the longest career in major leagues, including playing and managing??	luciobar1980	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	31	01-22-2025 05:47 PM
Negro Leagues Recognized As Major	riggs336	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	286	06-30-2021 12:43 PM
"Major League Baseball officially elevates Negro Leagues to 'Major League' status"	BCauley	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	3	12-16-2020 12:54 PM
1937 Who's Who in the Major Leagues Book (Ends 10PM EST Sunday 4/10)	Thecafewha	Live Auctions - Only 2-3 open, per member, at once.	0	04-07-2016 12:06 PM
Zeenut Players in Major Leagues	Archive	Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions	6	05-31-2005 09:12 PM