Problems with Standard Catalog Old Judge section

[Archive]

Posted By: Jay Miller

Tom---You make a good point, an exhaustive listing of Old Judge where the value of each variation was spelled out would be an extremely useful tool. Unfortunately, from a practical standpoint, it is an extremely difficult task to construct such a listing. With all due respect to the staff at SCD (or Beckett for that matter) they don't know the value of the cards in the set well enough to even attempt the task. The current catalog just doesn't contain incomplete information. It contains prices that are just dead wrong, and in some cases wrong by a factor of ten or more. Aside from the checklist value of the SCD listing, the "value" numbers are useless and should come with an equivalent of the warning on a pack of cigarettes.