Looking for prewar expert....

[broadhurstinc]

Congrats,
A very good deal if authentic.. try to post some scans of a few fronts and backs. Most likely will be able to tell right away if they athentic by having some pictures of them.

2 cards you have there could be extremely valuable:

doyle, ny natl - depending on which doyle.. if it's blue and his hands are up above his head you just hit the lottery.

o'hara, st. louis - one concern on this is you have it with a piedmont back which isn't possible.. should be a polar bear back

try to post some scans of these two and a few others so some board members can have a look.

Kris

[t206hound]

I'd have to agree that it is very unlikely that these are authentic. I responded to a Craigslist post recently and all of the cards were reproductions. Post a scan/photo of a few and we can let you know for sure.

[BleedinBlue]

Ohara sl piedmont + doyle ny NATl = fake

[Piratedogcardshows]

I was halfway expecting to see Wagner,Pittsburg listed after that seeing that Doyle Ny Nat & O'Hara.

[Sean1125]

I was halfway expecting non-sarcastic responses, but we can't all win can we?


If I made a bad buy, I made a bad buy, tell me no need to try and insinuate me as dumb, I told you I knew nothing on the subject already.

[danski496]

I agree with him, not all of us are experts , we collect for the fun of it as a hobby. Making a joke out of somebody doesn't show any respect in fellow collectors.

[BigDan502]

If he wanted non sarcasm he would have posted at least some pics.
He wanted a hearty pat on the back for a great find.

Good job buddy
Get em graded and there's a slew of guys that will help you make a nice return on that 750.
I honestly hope theyre all good and that they come back as 2s and 3s so I can buy them

[mrvster]

Hello Sean,

question- does your american beauty seen "shorter" than the other cards??
if so, might be authentic....btw....if they are, i would be interested in your american beauty back

lmk...when you get scans..

take care

Johnny