$100 to the first to identify...

[MW1]

$100 to the first to correctly identify all individuals in the following photograph:



Link to larger image

[ooo-ribay]

I can identify one for $20...

[slidekellyslide]

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay

I can identify one for $20...

Heh...I can identify 2 for $40.

[GoCubsGo32]

I raise you the 2... and I can name 3 for $60

[CrazyDiamond]

Who are 5 people who have never been in my kitchen

[DHogan]

I'd like to buy a vowel please.

[Lordstan]

L to R
Christy Walsh, Lou Gehrig, ?, Joe McCarthy, ?.
The guy in the middle looks familiar, but the guy on the end is a total mystery to me. Considering Walsh was the agent for both Gehrig and McCarthy, he could've arranged a meet and greet for anyone.
Is it for sale or just looking for information?

[Donscards]

Looking at McCarthy's glove, I would say the other 2 are Glove Salesmen

[slidekellyslide]

First guy doesn't look like Christy Walsh to me.

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by slidekellyslide

First guy doesn't look like Christy Walsh to me.

Agreed.

[Hot Springs Bathers]

Walsh, Gehrig, Frank Leahy, McCarthy, Red Grange

[bbcard1]

The last guy looks like Fred Gwynne.

[scooter729]

Originally Posted by CrazyDiamond

Who are 5 people who have never been in my kitchen

Awesome Cheers reference!

[ooo-ribay]

Originally Posted by slidekellyslide

First guy doesn't look like Christy Walsh to me.

I wouldn't know Christy Walsh from Adam...but that first guy looks like someone who might arrange for you to sleep with the fishes.

[iwantitiwinit]

i dont think thats Frank Leahy in the middle, it looks a bit like him but Leahy was born in 1908 which would make him 32 at most in this picture. The guy in the middle looks older than 32. Whomever it is was relatively well off based on how he's dressed expensive, shirt and suit.

[perezfan]

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay

I wouldn't know Christy Walsh from Adam...but that first guy looks like someone who might arrange for you to sleep with the fishes.

I believe his name is Vinny. Are last names required to win the $100?

[CrazyDiamond]

Originally Posted by scooter729

Awesome Cheers reference!

One of my favorite episodes. I couldn't resist

[Butch7999]

George Raft, Gehrig, Calvin Coolidge, McCarthy, Jean Harlow.

But all seriouslessness aside...
definitely not Walsh, nor Leahy, nor, and we're assuming this was just kidding the first place, not Grange neither.

[bbcard1]

I strongly suspect they are politicians. But as my wife reminds me, i am often wrong.

[Mark]

Which ballpark is it?

[slidekellyslide]

The guy in the middle looks like Joseph V. McKee who was mayor of New York for a very short time in 1932.

[bigfanNY]

Lou Gehrig Joe McCarthy Christy Walsh are easy Bobby jones and either Olin Dura or Walter Hagen? on the ends

[Mark]

Originally Posted by bigfanNY

Lou Gehrig Joe McCarthy Christy Walsh are easy Bobby jones and either Olin Dura or Walter Hagen? on the ends

Can't be Jones, who was 5' 8", while Gehrig stood at 6'.

[bn2cardz]

I really don't see how that could be Walsh.

Pic of Walsh:



The nose just doesn't match up at all.


As for the rest of the guesses in this thread I am starting some people need to see their doctor about getting diagnosed for Prosopagnosia.

It is similar to the ebay postings of photos that always have a young Wagner, Ruth, or Cobb on some farm team.

[CW]

Originally Posted by MW1

$100 to the first to correctly identify all individuals in the following photograph:

I see this same question was asked some time ago, so I'm just wondering...

do you actually know who all 5 individuals are in the photo, or are you stumped and asking for identification? If it's the latter, how will you ever know if someone gets it right?

Either way, it's nice of you to offer up the $100 reward.

[MW1]

Originally Posted by CW

I see this same question was asked some time ago, so I'm just wondering...

do you actually know who all 5 individuals are in the photo, or are you stumped and asking for identification? If it's the latter, how will you ever know if someone gets it right?

Either way, it's nice of you to offer up the $100 reward.

The first person to come up with reasonable matches gets the $100.

[Runscott]

Unless they are playing the Giants, they aren't in NYC.
Probably post-Ruth unless Gehrig is receiving an award, but I see no award. DiMaggio was a stud in 1937/38, so wouldn't he be in a photo-shoot like this?

Probably 1935-36, if at a World Series it is either the Giants (1936,37) or the Cubs (1938).

What stadium is that in the background? Polo Grounds? The field looks shitty and the guy on the left is wearing cowboy boots.

If you go with the 1935 or 36 World Series, away game at the Polo Grounds, does that help?

Okay, I give up. All I can come up with is this custom-made Wienermobile that was displayed in Chicago in 1936.

[darwinbulldog]

Originally Posted by CrazyDiamond

Who are 5 people who have never been in my kitchen

Nice reference.

[slidekellyslide]

Originally Posted by MW1

The first person to come up with reasonable matches gets the $100.

So you don't actually know who is in the photo? That info would have been pertinent at the start of this "contest".... Three of these guys in this photo could be joe blows from Jersey.

[MW1]

Originally Posted by slidekellyslide

Three of these guys in this photo could be joe blows from Jersey.

I doubt it. All of the available clues say otherwise.

[TimCarrollArt]

Could the man in the middle be Alfred Smith, governor of New York during the 20's?


Tim

[slidekellyslide]

Originally Posted by MW1

I doubt it. All of the available clues say otherwise.

What are the available clues? Nice clothes? Most everyone dressed like that in the 1930s.

[Footballdude]

From a football person who knows very little about early baseball legends:

Walsh, Gehrig, Charles Lindbergh, McCarthy, Howard Hughes.

[slidekellyslide]

Joseph McKee - NY City politician and interim Mayor in 1932. Looks like the guy in the middle to me.

[packs]

Definitely not Lindbergh. He would have only been about 30 when this photo was taken. The man in the middle looks to be at least ten to fifteen years older than that. Plus he doesn't really look like him.

I think there is a decent chance the man on the left next to Gehrig is Howard Hughes, who would have been 25 to 30 when this photo was taken:

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by packs

I think there is a decent chance the man on the left next to Gehrig is Howard Hughes, who would have been 25 to 30 when this photo was taken:

Not even vaguely.

[ramram]

Originally Posted by MW1

$100 to the first to correctly identify all individuals in the following photograph:



Link to larger image

The problem is, I can identify the five guys in front but I can only identify about half of the people sitting in the stands.

Rob M.

[gashouse34]

The guy on the far right appears to be the Alien Bounty Hunter from X Files.

[Tigerden]

Elliott Ness (far left) Lou Gehrig Christy Walsh (I doubt it) Joe McCarthey . The guy on the far right looks like William Veeck Sr. Photo possibly taken during 1932 World Series . This is my wild and I mean wild guess!!

[Tigerden]

Originally Posted by Tigerden

Elliott Ness (far left) Lou Gehrig Christy Walsh (I doubt it) Joe McCarthey . The guy on the far right looks like William Veeck Sr. Photo possibly taken during 1932 World Series . This is my wild and I mean wild guess!!

Ok I wish to amend my post to the following: Left to Right: Eliot Ness /Gehrig/ Harry Grabiner (Cubs Secretary)/McCarthy/ Bill Veeck Sr. (Cubs President)

[BBSD]

The dud on the left looks like Al Capone.

[Mark]

You'd think that Leon could at least identify the hats.

[Dto7]

photo was probably taken on their Spring training trip back to New York playing their minor league affiliates and ending up playing a Game at West Point.

[Davino]

Originally Posted by CrazyDiamond

Who are 5 people who have never been in my kitchen

lol