PWCC green cobb psa 5.5 going through the roof

[bobbyw8469]

PS - the only reason I consigned the Cy Young to him was to prove to you that I could get more on Ebay than what your lowball offer was. So, YOU were the only reason I sent it to him.

[calvindog]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

ps - the only reason i consigned the cy young to him was to prove to you that i could get more on ebay than what your lowball offer was. So, you were the only reason i sent it to him.

LOLOLOL

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

I'm not talking them down. I like Brent. I think he runs a top notch organization. People are stating facts though. Some of the auction results seem a little odd. Is it a crime to speak the truth? State facts?

Facts are real bastards.

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

PS - the only reason I consigned the Cy Young to him was to prove to you that I could get more on Ebay than what your lowball offer was. So, YOU were the only reason I sent it to him.

Its Christys, not Cy Young...I have no idea what Cy Young you are talking about..


.i do remember you netting less than you were asking for them on net54 (and to me )when all said and done actually..so you were highballing the cards .....if you want to talk facts..


It looks like I was wrong as far as not making an offer on one of the cards , I did offer 400 + paypal fees on the Christy Mathewson portrait but I said to send it to PWCC and I would offer more because of ebay bucks and incentives I didn't get with a direct deal..i don't think that's a 'lowball offer when I am within 10% of the net price to the seller after fees on a card going for 500 or less....if it is then I guess you call it highballing if the seller wants 10% more direct than what the seller nets at auction...or on the other card he had for sale in which he wanted 20% more than what he got on the card in net after the auction.



Part of the disagreement in price was that bobby said that SGC grades command a premium over PSA in prewar !

"I usually like PSA prices. For T206's though, SGC is king. They usually command higher prices"

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

PS - the only reason I consigned the Cy Young to him was to prove to you that I could get more on Ebay than what your lowball offer was. So, YOU were the only reason I sent it to him.

First we are talking about Christy's not Cy Young...not sure what you are talking about for the young.

haha and the fact you tried to sell them for weeks and weeks on net54 and kept saying would send them to auction ..and I kept asking you to make good on sending them to auction......so maybe I was the reason finally sent them to auction because was turning into a red lennox cobb..week after week....thank you for finally sending them....though you did get less net than you asked on net54, . and you do agree they were not shilled....



this is how all the cards you said did with PWCC including the mathewsons...funny no comments about saying got a ton on those cards or saying I made a low offer or anything....just this..

"Some of my stuff did OK...got killed on a couple....I think I can do just as good as he on minor stuff....still will use him for sets and Canadian cards (since I don't wish to ship international)"



I found the thread-- he said he was sending to consignment and 2 weeks later he still there with ttts.....he says had them priced at VCP so I guess everyone was lowballing him..... yeah IM the reason he consigned them.. lol..

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=197853

after price reductions..he asked 800 for the black hat and got less at auction 740 minus 13.5% in fees ($640)

http://www.pwccauctions.com/item.php?item_no=1064344

and for the portrait after price reductions he asked for 500 and got 510 minus 13.5% in fees ($442)

Looks like PWCC wasn't shilled there even though I assume many bidders there have 70% with PWCC but I didn't check..

[BeanTown]

Justin, welcome to the board and way to go to keep the card market red hot! Blue chip cards will always demand a premium, and there are many of them still way undervalued! I took heat and then had to read about (SCD weekly newspaper) how I over paid on a Joe Dimaggio zeenut with coupon when I won it for 12k and at thetime it booked for 2k. Well, price guides changed and should I say the guides caught up with actual market prices. When I sold the card it went through a live auction where it fetched way more than what I had paid.

Seems like we read the samething everytime a T206 Wagner sells. Has anyone ever lost money selling one of those??????

I agree with you Justin that PWCC is a good place to dealwith. Its refreshing to still see a trueauction through Ebay as now its mainly BIN with make an offer listings. PWCC follows all the Ebay rules and it seems that arguements made against them should be more withthe Ebay system.

If I was Brent I would ban anyone who retracts a bid more than once unless they have a good excuse and they conmunicate with them. They should look at every bidder on a per case basis. Plus, PWCC should ban any wiseguy, or should I say problem person as that should shut them up. I think many people don't always "practice" what they preach! They talk bad about you, and yet they bid in your auction...call their bluff and ban them if their facts don't add up!