To reholder or not to reholder

[Jetsfan]

For people who have used SGC to re-holder old cases/flips, did it go smoothly? Any issues? I’m considering sending a few in to be re-holdered. Now that PSA has purchased SGC, I’m wondering if the prices will go up from here and/or concern over potential that SGC would not allow reholdering
of older labels at some point in the future.

Thanks

Adam

[calvindog]

I do it all the time and have never had an issue.

[Jetsfan]

Thanks Jeff!

[jsfriedm]

Same here, smooth and quick process. PSA on the other hand...took four months.

[raulus]

What’s your motivation for reholdering? Just want the newer looking flip?

[JollyElm]

Originally Posted by raulus

What’s your motivation for reholdering? Just want the newer looking flip?

I wouldn't trust his motivation in any way. A Jets fan, NOT a Bills fan, in Western NY????
That just ain't right!!!!!

[Jetsfan]

Yes, motivation is primarily the newer looking flip. Also, if I were ever to sell any of these cards, I think most people prefer the new flips.

[Lucas00]

I actually like the old SGC label 90% as much as the new one. I would rather eat that last 10% and not have somebody handle the higher grade cards I own, haha. If I had a scan of a card and it looks like the corner was touched even a minute % from old scan to new reholder scan I just can't handle that.

If you are something like a t206 collector or low grade collector I think there's really zero downside aside from cost. But as a single player collector who is hyper focused on high grade sgc cards I can't do it.

[Jetsfan]

And Darren,
It’s been a rough 12 years as a Jets fan, especially in western NY. But at least nobody will accuse me of being a fair weather fan!

[Snowman]

I always reholder anything in an old slab. Never once had a problem. The only thing you need to worry about is if the slab is damaged or cracked, then they will treat it as a raw card and will regrade it per today's grading standards as they will not honor the grade in that case. If it's an old slab, that grade WILL go down 99% of the time.

[JollyElm]

Originally Posted by Jetsfan

And Darren,
It’s been a rough 12 years as a Jets fan, especially in western NY. But at least nobody will accuse me of being a fair weather fan!

Although born a Jets fan in the shadow of Shea Stadium, I've been a Bills psychopath for as long as I can remember now. When I have to root against the Jetties the two times a year they face off against each other, I explain it away to my friends by saying, "Look, at least you guys have a Super Bowl win. My Bills don't."

[BobbyStrawberry]

I actually prefer SGCs old labels to the new ones. If could get the new ones swapped out for one of the old green ones, I would do it!

[MikeGarcia]

Originally Posted by BobbyStrawberry

I actually prefer SGCs old labels to the new ones. If could get the new ones swapped out for one of the old green ones, I would do it!

Nostalgia and class.

[brianp-beme]

I would only reholder boulders. Then if I lofted them up I could theoretically have over the shoulder boulder reholders.


Brian (I'm glad others actually answered the question before me)

[Bigdaddy]

Originally Posted by brianp-beme

I would only reholder bolders. Then if I lofted them up I could theoretically have over the shoulder bolder reholders.


Brian (I'm glad others actually answered the question before me)

You could 'get him in the gotcha'

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by BobbyStrawberry

I actually prefer SGCs old labels to the new ones. If could get the new ones swapped out for one of the old green ones, I would do it!

+1

[MikeGarcia]

Originally Posted by Casey2296

+1

[parkplace33]

Originally Posted by Jetsfan

For people who have used SGC to re-holder old cases/flips, did it go smoothly? Any issues? I’m considering sending a few in to be re-holdered. Now that PSA has purchased SGC, I’m wondering if the prices will go up from here and/or concern over potential that SGC would not allow reholdering
of older labels at some point in the future.

Thanks

Adam

Adam,

What cards are you thinking about reholdering?

I am wary of it. I have gotten lambasted on this board before about my concerns, but my thought it is: Why rock the boat?

[NYYFan63]

I just submitted a Green Cobb in an old SGC holder to SGC to get reholdered.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Yoda]

Originally Posted by JollyElm

Although born a Jets fan in the shadow of Shea Stadium, I've been a Bills psychopath for as long as I can remember now. When I have to root against the Jetties the two times a year they face off against each other, I explain it away to my friends by saying, "Look, at least you guys have a Super Bowl win. My Bills don't."

The Bills looked ready to take on the world after their performance the other night. Josh Allen was terrific as usual. I think he would run through a brick wall for an extra yard to make a 1st down.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by Jetsfan

For people who have used SGC to re-holder old cases/flips, did it go smoothly? Any issues? I’m considering sending a few in to be re-holdered. Now that PSA has purchased SGC, I’m wondering if the prices will go up from here and/or concern over potential that SGC would not allow reholdering
of older labels at some point in the future.

Thanks

Adam

If it is just a few I would send them in if I liked the new flips better. I personally like the look of new flips way better.

[jh691626]

I did it once for a T206--went great, super fast, looked nice!