Cartwright Daguerreotype assessment ?? Question

[bigfanNY]

Originally Posted by molenick

At the risk of getting into the dispute about the cabinet in question:

1) I think most people agree that photo matching is a useful tool.

2) As per the earlier threads, not everyone agrees that the known photos of Comiskey match the player identified as Comiskey in the cabinet.

3) Experts can disagree. The 44-page analysis of the Cartwright dag is an example of this.

4) The fact that experts can disagree does not mean the player in the cabinet is or isn't Comiskey. It just means that there may be differing opinions.

Michael In point 2 of your post you say that not everyone agrees on the Comiskey photo. I just re read both of the Posts where Directly claims that Comiskey is in this Photo and No One agrees with that statment. 12 years ago Everyone who comented said not Comiskey and this year the same result. NO ONE ON THE THREAD THINKS THAT CHARLES COMISKEY IS IN THE PICTURE.
Did you access some other source for your statment?
You dont need mine or anyone's permission to post an option here or anywhere. But in both of those threads clearly everyone agreed that it was not Charles Comiskey in that photo. It was clearly pointed out that his eye color and ears were different in the photos. So it seems very clear that the picture is Absolutely not Charles Comiskey. So I just wondering your source.