Jim Crandell's personal thread

[Archive]

Posted By: JimCrandell

Leon,

Thank you--glad we stumbled on a situation that works for all.

This is why I disagree with you.

For sake of argument lets say I did $250K of business with XYZ Auction House and I bought a card for $10K that is a PSA 8. I then take it in to show Dave Forman--he looks at it and says this is beyond the shadow of a doubt a trimmed card. The president of the auction house comes to SGC listens to Dave and agrees. So that I will keep doing business in the future with him he writes me a check for $10K. Then he goes to PSA and attempts to get a refund.

I would maintain that an auction house would likely do that under these circumstances and that it is a good decision to do it.

But I may be wrong?