Keurajian vs Beckett

[theshleps]

Compare https://sports.ha.com/itm/autographs...=MyBids-101116 and Page 223 Simmons 5 in Ron's 2nd edition. If Ron is right, this is bad. As Ive mentioned before Beckett is always alittle too liberal in passing things IMO but with PSA taking very few items there is a large increase in Beckett slabs. Also to me the Koufax and possibly Drysdale on this are iffy https://www.ebay.com/itm/37378869956...AAAOSwiaFhjb~N

[jad22]

Originally Posted by theshleps

Compare https://sports.ha.com/itm/autographs...=MyBids-101116 and Page 223 Simmons 5 in Ron's 2nd edition. If Ron is right, this is bad. As Ive mentioned before Beckett is always alittle too liberal in passing things IMO but with PSA taking very few items there is a large increase in Beckett slabs. Also to me the Koufax and possibly Drysdale on this are iffy https://www.ebay.com/itm/37378869956...AAAOSwiaFhjb~N

That does not look like the normal Simmons autographed Artvue.

[Duluth Eskimo]

No way that Simmons is good.

[theshleps]

went for $16,000. Shows what a slab will do

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by theshleps

went for $16,000. Shows what a slab will do

That is very surprising

[Klrdds]

The slab means everything in autographs as well as cards. Forget the legitimacy of the actual item. It seems to me that this item would have stood out as questionable at best, but people don't educate themselves as they used to or should continue to do they just go with the label on the slab and rely on that only.
PS FWIW Beckett and Grad are my least favorite of authenticators and should I say to me the least authoritative / confidence generating of the TPAs as well.

[theshleps]

Originally Posted by Klrdds

The slab means everything in autographs as well as cards. Forget the legitimacy of the actual item. It seems to me that this item would have stood out as questionable at best, but people don't educate themselves as they used to or should continue to do they just go with the label on the slab and rely on that only.
PS FWIW Beckett and Grad are my least favorite of authenticators and should I say to me the least authoritative / confidence generating of the TPAs as well.

I agree about Beckett and Grad. In recent auctions IMO the Clementes and Jackie Robinson they sold with Beckett slabs had some questionable ones tho it did not stop the high bids

[Republicaninmass]

Originally Posted by theshleps

I agree about Beckett and Grad. In recent auctions IMO the Clementes and Jackie Robinson they sold with Beckett slabs had some questionable ones tho it did not stop the high bids

I believe the jackies are currently resurfacing in auctions houses...try to find the next Rube

[Klrdds]

Originally Posted by Republicaninmass

I believe the jackies are currently resurfacing in auctions houses...try to find the next Rube

I agree 100% and the Rubes will be lining up to bid