Is there a specifc thread to ask for a legit check?

[Seven]

Hi All,

I didn't want to post in the improper place, but there's an ebay auction of an ungraded card that I was interested in, and I wanted a better set of eyes then my own to take a look at it to determine whether or not it's real. The Seller has good feedback and has multiple auctions running, though I doubt that means much. Thanks!

Edit: Also I'm not sure of the etiquette when it comes to posting listings. Thanks again

Link: https://www.ebay.com/itm/1952-BOWMAN...53.m1438.l2649

[RL]

after reading the sellers feedback, I would not buy from her

[Seven]

Originally Posted by RL

after reading the sellers feedback, I would not buy from her

Appreciate the insight. Any particular reason why? What should I be on the lookout for?

[vthobby]

Her last 2 or 3 Negatives were $1500 and up and they claim fraud. She is in Canada which sucks also. The Mantle appears diamond cut but also trimmed on the top edge. Stay away/

Peace, Mike

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by vtgmsc

Her last 2 or 3 Negatives were $1500 and up and they claim fraud. She is in Canada which sucks also. The Mantle appears diamond cut but also trimmed on the top edge. Stay away/

Peace, Mike

But even AUTHENTIC only, the Mantle has some value.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Card is 100% trimmed, and rather violently at that.

[vthobby]

That was implied.......he was asking an opinion on the card. If someone does not know that a 1952 Bowman Mantle holds value regardless then they have been living in Norway under some Moss.

It's most likely an atuhentic on the 1 to 10 scale. Values are all over the internet for an Authentic slabbed 1952 Mantle.

I's stay away regardless due to the recent negatives and her being in Canada.

You could get the same thrill and spend $1000 in overseas online gambling.

Good luck winning or ever getting your money back! Same thing!

Peace, Mike

[Seven]

Thank you everyone, for weighing in on this. Definitely going to stay away, I could tell something was a little off but I wanted to defer to better judgement.

[drcy]

As far as board etiquette goes, this is the Pre-War section so the post war section is more appropriate. Though, in reality, it was fine to post your post in this section.

It is always okay to ask about the authenticity of an auction item, even when it is ongoing.

Some people complain about "outing" ongoing auctions, but asking about authenticity is fine and what the board should be about.

And the rule against outing an auction is just some people's opinions, and there is no written rule anywhere on this board against it.

[Leon]

+1...

Originally Posted by drcy

As far as board etiquette goes, this is the Pre-War section so the post war section is more appropriate. Though, in reality, it was fine to post your post in this section.

It is always okay to ask about
the authenticity of an auction item, even when it is ongoing.

Some people complain about "outing" ongoing auctions, but asking about authenticity is fine and what the board should be about.

And the rule against outing an auction is just some people's opinions, and there is no written rule anywhere on this board against it.

[grainsley]

I'm just trying to figure out why Canada is such a bad place!

[vthobby]

Grant,

I love Canada......Montreal, Quebec City, Ottawa...... absolute heaven!

All I meant was the Covid Situation and mailing from Country to Country.

I'd buy the item from Canada if the seller was 100% and the item was something I wanted!

No offense intended! I love Canada! Aucune infraction prévue! J'adore le canada!

Peace, Mike
Paix, Mike

[grainsley]

Je suis tres jolie, merci bien, mon ami!

(I have always thought it was a nice place, in spite of the mail being slower than usual here, which we were used to!)

[thatkidfromjerrymaguire]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

Card is 100% trimmed, and rather violently at that.

Just curious about how you can tell 100% that it has been trimmed. Off centered cuts are fairly common in 1952 Bowman (i.e. one corner higher than another).

Check out this listing from the latest REA auction:

https://bid.robertedwardauctions.com...e?itemid=65598

Severely higher on the top right corner. But yes, just because it's in an SGC holder doesn't necessarily mean this one isn't trimmed as well. *sigh*

I'm not questioning your judgement, I just want to know what else you are looking for. Is there an edge characteristic?