Mickey mantle cards...how many exist?

sflayank · #1 04-21-2020, 07:49 PM

Let's see opinions..this is my opinion..on 10
Where I put LESS in caps I believe less than 5
Tip top bread label ...more
53 stahl. More
53 yamakatsu LESS
53 briggs more
53 Briggs panel. LESS
54 stahl more
54 mascot dog food. LESS
55 armour coins several colors LESS than 5
55 exhibit postcard. More
55 exhibit mutoscope more
55 stahl. more
58 mission soda. Less
59 bazooka complete box less
59 dads less
59 venezuela. More
59 yoo hoo. Less
60 bazooka box. LESS
60 opc tatoo picture. LESS
61 bazooka box. LESS
61 dice game. LESS
61 post cereal box. LESS
62 bazooka box. LESS
62 jello box. LESS
62 pitts exhibit 5 of cluds. Less
62 pitts exhibit 8 of clubs. Less
62 post cereal box. LESS
62 post canadian box. LESS
63 bazooka box. Less
63 mask more
63 jello box. LESS
63 post cereal box LESS
64 bazooka box. Less
64 meadowgold milk carton. More
64 meadowgold 2% carton. LESS
64 meadowgold chocolate milk carton. LESS
64 glove box panel. More
65 bazooka box. Less
66 bazooka box. Less
66 punchout. Less
67 bazooka box. Less
67 disc. More
67 stand up die cut less
67 stand up proof. Less
67 punchouts aparicio stottlemyre. More
67 punchouts salmon kaat. More
67 punchouts 3 card panel. Less
68 american oil right side. LESS
68 bazooka box. Less
68 disc. Less
69 rawlings. Less

ALR-bishop · #2 04-21-2020, 08:30 PM

6

sflayank · #3 04-21-2020, 08:32 PM

?

hcv123 · #4 04-21-2020, 08:48 PM

I've highlighted in red comments or differing opinion

Tip top bread label ...more
53 stahl. More
53 yamakatsu LESS
53 briggs more
53 Briggs panel. LESS
54 stahl more
54 mascot dog food. LESS
55 armour coins several colors LESS than 5
55 exhibit postcard. More
55 exhibit mutoscope more
55 stahl. more
58 mission soda. Less
59 bazooka complete box less
59 dads less
59 venezuela. More
59 yoo hoo. Less
60 bazooka box. LESS - Is there even a single 1 confirmed to exist?
60 opc tatoo picture. LESS
61 bazooka box. LESS - Is there even a single 1 confirmed to exist?
61 dice game. LESS
61 post cereal box. LESS -Is there even a single 1 confirmed to exist?
62 bazooka box. LESS
62 jello box. LESS
62 pitts exhibit 5 of cluds. Less
62 pitts exhibit 8 of clubs. Less
62 post cereal box. LESS Is there even a single 1 confirmed to exist?
62 post canadian box. LESS Is there even a single 1 confirmed to exist?
63 bazooka box. Less
63 mask more
63 jello box. LESS
63 post cereal box LESS Is there even a single 1 confirmed to exist?
64 bazooka box. Less
64 meadowgold milk carton. More
64 meadowgold 2% carton. LESS
64 meadowgold chocolate milk carton. LESS
64 glove box panel. More
65 bazooka box. Less
66 bazooka box. Less - I believe more on this one
66 punchout. Less
67 bazooka box. Less - This is a toughie, but not sure about less than 5 - likely less than 10
67 disc. More
67 stand up die cut less
67 stand up proof. Less
67 punchouts aparicio stottlemyre. More
67 punchouts salmon kaat. More
67 punchouts 3 card panel. Less
68 american oil right side. LESS
68 bazooka box. Less - This is another close one - if we're talking with both sets of end panels, I agree.
68 disc. Less
69 rawlings. Less

sflayank · #5 04-21-2020, 08:52 PM

Hi
67 have listed less than 10
The others not confirmed to exist? I agree

quitcrab · #6 04-22-2020, 02:09 AM

How many Mascot dog food cards out there? One known example????
Have anymore been discovered ?

sflayank · #7 04-22-2020, 06:04 AM

mascot
1 roberts
2 berra
1 mantle

quitcrab · #8 04-22-2020, 07:18 AM

Sounds like a easy set to complete ! 3 cards ! 😀. Thanks for the info in mascot dog food.
How many full 1964 Bazooka Stamp panels and 68 Full Topps action stickers panels of Mantle do you think exist? I would think the number is under 500 but who knows ?

sflayank · #9 04-22-2020, 09:55 AM

Way less than 500

Bestdj777 · #10 05-01-2020, 05:30 AM

I wish I’d seen this before I traded my mint Mission Soda away.... it was a cool item but I always assumed it was more common.

bswhiten · #11 05-01-2020, 08:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bestdj777

I wish I’d seen this before I traded my mint Mission Soda away.... it was a cool item but I always assumed it was more common.

Chris, check out what Matt did with his... Happy with my missing corner example

10 are graded at psa, so i would guess more exist.

Bestdj777 · #12 05-01-2020, 06:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bswhiten

Chris, check out what Matt did with his... Happy with my missing corner example

10 are graded at psa, so i would guess more exist.

I like that a lot. I traded mine for a Holiday Inn postcard—it is one of only three I’ve seen in years of collecting and I wanted to complete that run. The Mission Soda premium is a great item though and I miss it.

AustinMike · #13 05-02-2020, 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bswhiten

Chris, check out what Matt did with his... Happy with my missing corner example

10 are graded at psa, so i would guess more exist.

That's pretty interesting Ben. What's the top part made of - is it a painting? Also, he put two graded copies in the one display?

I would say more than 10 exist. I have an ungraded copy.

AustinMike · #14 05-02-2020, 04:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sflayank

Let's see opinions..this is my opinion..on 10
Where I put LESS in caps I believe less than 5
Tip top bread label ...more
53 stahl. More
53 yamakatsu LESS
53 briggs more
53 Briggs panel. LESS
54 stahl more
54 mascot dog food. LESS
55 armour coins several colors LESS than 5
55 exhibit postcard. More
55 exhibit mutoscope more
55 stahl. more
58 mission soda. Less
59 bazooka complete box less
59 dads less
59 venezuela. More
59 yoo hoo. Less
60 bazooka box. LESS
60 opc tatoo picture. LESS
61 bazooka box. LESS
61 dice game. LESS
61 post cereal box. LESS
62 bazooka box. LESS
62 jello box. LESS
62 pitts exhibit 5 of cluds. Less
62 pitts exhibit 8 of clubs. Less
62 post cereal box. LESS
62 post canadian box. LESS
63 bazooka box. Less
63 mask more
63 jello box. LESS
63 post cereal box LESS
64 bazooka box. Less
64 meadowgold milk carton. More
64 meadowgold 2% carton. LESS
64 meadowgold chocolate milk carton. LESS
64 glove box panel. More
65 bazooka box. Less
66 bazooka box. Less
66 punchout. Less
67 bazooka box. Less
67 disc. More
67 stand up die cut less
67 stand up proof. Less
67 punchouts aparicio stottlemyre. More
67 punchouts salmon kaat. More
67 punchouts 3 card panel. Less
68 american oil right side. LESS
68 bazooka box. Less
68 disc. Less
69 rawlings. Less

What about the '68 Venezuelan? I haven't seen very many of those. Are these only items that PSA grades and has as part of the Mantle registry? I don't see the late 60s Country Cookin' premium on the list. I don't see many of those but I would bet there are more than 10. Also, the '51 self-promotion card that K. Eisenhauer says Mantle had printed up to pass out. Another item hardly seen. Probably more than 10. Other than the Mission Soda, I really couldn't argue with what Howard said.

Bestdj777 · #15 05-02-2020, 05:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AustinMike

What about the '68 Venezuelan? I haven't seen very many of those. Are these only items that PSA grades and has as part of the Mantle registry? I don't see the late 60s Country Cookin' premium on the list. I don't see many of those but I would bet there are more than 10. Also, the '51 self-promotion card that K. Eisenhauer says Mantle had printed up to pass out. Another item hardly seen. Probably more than 10. Other than the Mission Soda, I really couldn't argue with what Howard said.

For the promo, I believe, when I purchased mine, that Kelly had 5-6 of them. I think I got 3 of them (sold one to Chris and not sure who I sold the other duplicate to—you?). I think the other 2 went to another collector. Other than those 5-6, the only one I am aware of is the one PSA shows on their site with the 1951 signature. I still kick myself for not buying that as one of us should have gotten it.

Bestdj777 · #16 05-02-2020, 05:57 PM

The 68 Venezuelan has 23 graded by PSA, although that seems high. I’d bet there are less than 5 of the 59 cream back ones though-I’ve only seen two.

AustinMike · #17 05-03-2020, 07:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bestdj777

For the promo, I believe, when I purchased mine, that Kelly had 5-6 of them. I think I got 3 of them (sold one to Chris and not sure who I sold the other duplicate to—you?). I think the other 2 went to another collector. Other than those 5-6, the only one I am aware of is the one PSA shows on their site with the 1951 signature. I still kick myself for not buying that as one of us should have gotten it.

Chris, I got my Mantle promo cards from KE. I got 2 from him and I remember having a chance to select which 2. Looking back at emails, I apparently bought one from him, then bought another a year or so later. I can't find emails for the first one, but for the second one he sent a picture showing 5 of the promos with 2 of them marked as sold. I bought 1 of the 3 remaining ones.

AustinMike · #18 05-03-2020, 07:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bestdj777

The 68 Venezuelan has 23 graded by PSA, although that seems high. I’d bet there are less than 5 of the 59 cream back ones though-I’ve only seen two.

Wow, I am surprised is shows 23 graded '68 Venezuelans. I didn't realize there were that many floating around.

hcv123 · #19 05-03-2020, 10:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AustinMike

Wow, I am surprised is shows 23 graded '68 Venezuelans. I didn't realize there were that many floating around.

Of those - 14 are graded 2 or less and 25 is just not that many to go around between Venezuelan collectors and Mantle collectors - so you don't see them very often! Grateful to have one of the 4's for a long time now. Pretty sure I won it in a Mr Mint auction - a lot with 3 Venezuelans (64,67 and 68?) and a 66 and 67 O Pee Chee.
The 59 cream backs are crazy hard!

bswhiten · #20 05-03-2020, 03:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AustinMike

That's pretty interesting Ben. What's the top part made of - is it a painting? Also, he put two graded copies in the one display?

Top part is cut baseball cards that Tim Carroll crafts into works of art.

Here are a couple of other Micks that Matt has with the actual cards. Pretty cool imo.

Bestdj777 · #21 05-03-2020, 03:56 PM

That’s insane. I love it.

AustinMike · #22 05-04-2020, 06:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bswhiten

Top part is cut baseball cards that Tim Carroll crafts into works of art.

Here are a couple of other Micks that Matt has with the actual cards. Pretty cool imo.

Those are fantastic! I have absolutely zero artistic skills.

It's also pretty neat to actually see a Yamakatsu card.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
FS: 1988 Baseball Cards magazine - Mickey Mantle interview, 1951-52 reprint cards	scooter729	Baseball Memorabilia B/S/T	1	03-03-2019 12:53 PM
FS 1954 Bowman Mickey Mantle PSA 3 & 1960 Topps AS Mickey Mantle PSA 3	frankhardy	1950 to 1959 Baseball cards- B/S/T	0	02-08-2014 11:30 AM
Let's see some Mickey Mantle cards!!	Archive	Postwar Baseball Cards Forum (Pre-1980)	57	03-15-2009 08:29 PM
1933 Goudey Babe Ruth, 1956 Topps Mickey Mantle, 1953 Bowman Color Mickey Mantle for trade	Archive	1950 to 1959 Baseball cards- B/S/T	4	04-07-2008 06:48 PM
FS: Mickey Mantle Cards	Archive	1950 to 1959 Baseball cards- B/S/T	0	12-19-2007 09:09 AM