Any chance these autos are legit?

[scmavl]

I bought this photo when I first got back into the hobby, a couple of years ago. I knew NOTHING about autos and assumed if someone said it was good, then it was. Here is a Branch Rickey & Fred Haney signed photo.

Opinions?

[GrayGhost]

Rickey looks bad from the few Ive seen. Haney, I would have no idea.

[JimStinson]

My GUESS and its just a guess is that Haney signed it and wrote Branch's name. Check out the formation of the "B" in Branch and compare it to the "F" in Fred

[scmavl]

Thanks guys. Rickey signed his name a few different ways but recently (since I've learned a little about autos), I don't like it at all. Looks like someone was practicing their "Ruth" R's on it, haha... I've no idea about Haney but they both look like the same hand (or at least the same pen) to me.

[T206Collector]

Originally Posted by JimStinson

My GUESS and its just a guess is that Haney signed it and wrote Branch's name. Check out the formation of the "B" in Branch and compare it to the "F" in Fred

I thought the same thing too

[scooter729]

I've got a Haney signed card PSA/DNA, and the signature on that card (very light going down the left of the card) seems to match up with the picture...

[scmavl]

Thanks guys. So the consensus is real Haney and bad Rickey (possibly Haney signed)? Any more input is welcome but I am inclined to agree with this conclusion...