Maybe people are buying the card vs. the slab

[Arazi4442]

Just scrolling through the HA auction ending tonight and noticed two ‘52 Mantles both graded 3. The centered PSA 3 is currently going for $100K+ and the poorly centered SGC 3 is less than $30K.

I can appreciate the price discrepancy between PSA vs. SGC and centered vs. off-centered but a 4X difference is pretty substantial.

[irv]

Originally Posted by Arazi4442

Just scrolling through the HA auction ending tonight and noticed two ‘52 Mantles both graded 3. The centered PSA 3 is currently going for $100K+ and the poorly centered SGC 3 is less than $30K.

I can appreciate the price discrepancy between PSA vs. SGC and centered vs. off-centered but a 4X difference is pretty substantial.

Centering/presentation, among other things, is huge.

Could also be the age of the flips and when each was graded?

I believe it was just last week where a very nice centered 1.5 sold for twice as much, maybe more or slightly less, than a 2.5. Both PSA, IIRC?

I also believe, since there are 2, or maybe more, the most presentable/nicest one will get most of the attention and bids right up until the very end. If the nicest/centered one sells first, then the second one will definitely close the price gap at the very end.

[MattyC]

Correct about the 1.5 outselling the 2.5 by a significant margin on eBay just the other day.

Encouraging to see people buying the card more frequently these days. Anyone shopping for a 311 definitely sees after a while how precious few look like that PSA 3 at Heritage right now. In ten years I’ve still only seen 10 that centered and that includes a ten and a nine.

[irv]

Originally Posted by MattyC

Correct about the 1.5 outselling the 2.5 by a significant margin on eBay just the other day.

Encouraging to see people buying the card more frequently these days. Anyone shopping for a 311 definitely sees after a while how precious few look like that PSA 3 at Heritage right now. In ten years I’ve still only seen 10 that centered and that includes a ten and a nine.

By far the nicest looking 3 I ever recall seeing.

Imo, there is no comparison between the 2.

[MattyC]

I agree. Has to be the best looking specimen in the hobby in the 1-3 grade range. In hand or a wall display at a casual distance that 3 will hit the eye with such beauty. Final hammer all in was 162k.

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by MattyC

I agree. Has to be the best looking specimen in the hobby in the 1-3 grade range. In hand or a wall display at a casual distance that 3 will hit the eye with such beauty. Final hammer all in was 162k.

The SGC 3 which had very poor centering went for only $50,400 so quite a difference between them.

[irv]

Originally Posted by MattyC

I agree. Has to be the best looking specimen in the hobby in the 1-3 grade range. In hand or a wall display at a casual distance that 3 will hit the eye with such beauty. Final hammer all in was 162k.

Originally Posted by jayshum

The SGC 3 which had very poor centering went for only $50,400 so quite a difference between them.

I am not surprised by that disparity at all. Like has been mentioned, that was one heck of a centered PSA 3 Mantle.

[dio]

Price for the psa 3 is NOT only for the centering but overall appeal in other area as well. Try a scratch up faded color bad registration 3 and worn corner psa 3 with perfect centering and you won't get that price. The SGC is very close to MC

[Gorditadogg]

Originally Posted by MattyC

Correct about the 1.5 outselling the 2.5 by a significant margin on eBay just the other day.



Encouraging to see people buying the card more frequently these days. Anyone shopping for a 311 definitely sees after a while how precious few look like that PSA 3 at Heritage right now. In ten years I’ve still only seen 10 that centered and that includes a ten and a nine.

Boy, I don't this is the case at all. It is a great market for selling the flip, not as great if you have a really nice card that you want to get 200% VCP for.

If I were selling (which I am not) I would be unloading all my average and below cards now, and saving the better ones for when the market levels off and the nice cards stand out more.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk