Guess the grade?

[irv]

I just received these cards today and although I don't have the experience/knowledge that most do on here, I thought I would put that knowledge/experience to the test.

These cards were slabbed by PSA and that is all I am going to tell you for now. Tell me what grade each card received and why and I will post the full pics with the PSA grade later/tomorrow. (Cards were posted alphabetically by first name)

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

well knowing that doing this by scan is practically impossible and you didn't give us back images I would guess 5,4,6 in the order you posted. Though I am worried about the marks on Smalley's top border and he may actually be a 3 or trimmed!

[irv]

Oops.

[irv]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

well knowing that doing this by scan is practically impossible and you didn't give us back images I would guess 5,4,6 in the order you posted. Though I am worried about the marks on Smalley's top border and he may actually be a 3 or trimmed!

Backs are all good with no visible marks, stains or anything else I can notice. (There are no qualifiers either, just to be clear)

I am actually surprised by the lack of guesses? Are people afraid they might be wrong or is it something else.

Your guesses are interesting, Scott, and likely close to what I would have guessed as well.

Forgot to add, but didn't want to give out much info, 2 of the cards were recently graded from raw/new submits.

[Stonepony]

4,5,6

[gregr2]

3-4-4


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[David W]

3,4,5

[111gecko]

4,5,5.5

[bnorth]

4,4,6

[vthobby]

4, 2, 6

Peace, Mike

4, 4, 5

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

I had the Shea lower because I thought it had surface damage, again the problems of doing this by scan. pretty happy with my grades considering the handicaps of doing it this way.

[irv]

Originally Posted by vtgmsc

4, 2, 6

Peace, Mike

Originally Posted by uniship

4,2,5.5

Originally Posted by deeg23

I'm gonna go with 4 - 3 - 5

From what I have learned/seen since joining this site, I, if it were me guessing, would have picked around these grades as well.

Originally Posted by dclarkraiders

I was in the process of guessing when the actual grades were posted. I was to low on all of them except Smalley which I guessed correctly and Kuzava which I guessed a 5. Giving Kuzava a 3 seems harsh to me.

Thanks for posting

Duane

I agree, the Kuzava looks much nicer in hand, and when I received, I couldn't figure out the grading with this one? I purchased it already graded so it was win for me. (Better pic below)

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

I had the Shea lower because I thought it had surface damage, again the problems of doing this by scan. pretty happy with my grades considering the handicaps of doing it this way.

It does, Scott. Those marks you see are scuffs and like I mentioned, it has clear dents/marks in 3 places that you can't see in the scan. This card was generously graded, and then some!

I also liked your guesses. Like I mentioned earlier, mine would have been very close as well if these weren't my cards.