1962 Jell-O Pudding Cards - Help

[skil55voy]

Originally Posted by cannonballsun View Post
These 2 boxes were from the recent Memory Lane Auction. The Aaron went for over $4000, the Maris went for around $2000.
The Aaron/Orange box was not yet on Ken's list.


I have added the Aaron-Orange Box to my list. I also have found that card number 88 Bill Tuttle may be from Lemon Flavor Jell-O. I am trying to get a good scan to come out. I can see Yellow outside the border at the bottom of the end of the statistics.

[cannonballsun]

Originally Posted by skil55voy

Originally Posted by cannonballsun View Post
These 2 boxes were from the recent Memory Lane Auction. The Aaron went for over $4000, the Maris went for around $2000.
The Aaron/Orange box was not yet on Ken's list.


I have added the Aaron-Orange Box to my list. I also have found that card number 88 Bill Tuttle may be from Lemon Flavor Jell-O. I am trying to get a good scan to come out. I can see Yellow outside the border at the bottom of the end of the statistics.

This is a Tuttle box (orange gelatin) that I once owned, since traded away.

[Thedudeabides]

My first post, and with it, a request for the estimated value of the pictured 1962 Jello boxes. I submitted these for an auction, and they ended up 'missing'. Needless to say, I was not pleased with a $100 offer of restitution.

Ken Marks, was kind enough to offer his thoughts, and I wanted to get some other opinions. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

[Lucas00]

Originally Posted by Thedudeabides

My first post, and with it, a request for the estimated value of the pictured 1962 Jello boxes. I submitted these for an auction, and they ended up 'missing'. Needless to say, I was not pleased with a $100 offer of restitution.

Ken Marks, was kind enough to offer his thoughts, and I wanted to get some other opinions. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Based on prices listed by previous posts in this thread that is terrible compensation. If a Roger Maris went for $2000 I would expect Ernie Banks to match that or come close.

[whiteymet]

Originally Posted by Thedudeabides

My first post, and with it, a request for the estimated value of the pictured 1962 Jello boxes. I submitted these for an auction, and they ended up 'missing'. Needless to say, I was not pleased with a $100 offer of restitution.

Ken Marks, was kind enough to offer his thoughts, and I wanted to get some other opinions. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Whatever Ken Marks tells you you can take to the bank ( or auction house in this case)!

Are you willing to say which auction house? Or PM me with this info if you don't want to make it public

[brian1961]

Hey, THEDUDEABIDES, I am so very, very sorry to hear about your loss. That is downright lousy. Their crumbum restitution is robbery, and I think you could take the matter to court. Straight-up honest, bro, I feel just horrible for you. It had to be brutal giving those up in the first place. Ouch X 10 to the 3rd power!!!!!

I hope Ken and some others come to your aid and support.

A strong, brotherly hug to you, bud. That does not make my day. That auction house better look around A WHOLE LOT CLOSER, 'CAUSE I THINK THEY KNOW WHERE THEY ARE!!!!!!! I know things can get lost, but any auction house knows that's one of the paramount rules----YOU DON'T, UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES, LOSE TRACK OF YOUR CONSIGNORS' GEMS!!!!!!!

--- Brian Powell

[hcv123]

In the first place to "lose" them and in the second place to only offer you $100 is despicable - as the other post suggested - either privately or publicly - really would love to know which auction house this is. Pricing is really hard as they surface and sell so rarely. I would say a floor value of $800-$1K on the Banks and $500-$750 on the Santo with the possibility with the right competitive bidding on them that they could go considerably higher.

[Thedudeabides]

Many thanks to those who've responded so far, and for the PM's. Ken Marks has been of great assistance. Harder to find a nicer guy. Mark