Collection Value

[garymc]

A few weeks back I posted about getting insurance and got great impute and direction. I find myself again needing a little more help ? I need to establish values on my cards.

Is there a web site that has a search engine for pre-war or a book or magazine that I can buy to get current prices ?

https://www.flickr.com/photos/151843924@N04/albums

[jcmtiger]

My suggestion would be to check any and as many auction sites for recent prices. And ebay.

[Foo3112]

I've been using VCP for about 8 years now. Annual subscription cost is $190 I believe.

https://vintagecardprices.com/

[garymc]

I failed to mention that my collection is 90% RAW. I started collecting in 1992 and it has been only the last couple of years that I've been getting graded cards in trades and at auction.

[raulus]

Originally Posted by garymc

I failed to mention that my collection is 90% RAW. I started collecting in 1992 and it has been only the last couple of years that I've been getting graded cards in trades and at auction.

Insurance companies will parrot the terms "like kind and quality" to you over and over again. Looks like you have a good photo log of a lot of your pieces, which should help to document the precise items and their quality. Hopefully it's complete.

The gist of the insurance companies' approach is that they will either find replacements that are of similar quality, or they will cut you a check for the amount of your coverage if they can't replace it.

My advice would be to estimate the amount that you would need to pay to replace each item if you had to go out and buy it retail, which is often a lot higher than auction prices. For some stuff, it's not easy to find comps, particularly with raw obscure pieces, just because they're that hard to find, and come onto the market very infrequently. Ebay is certainly a good resource. You can also use cardfinder, which is free, and has the added benefit of including raw cards, although I'm not sure how complete their database is.

In some cases, any given item might not have sold recently, so you'll be relying on old sales data to pick a number. Just make sure to factor in the dramatic runup in prices over the last couple of years.

Ultimately, for some things it might be tough to find much, so you will probably just have to give it your best guess. I would aim a little on the high side, just to give yourself some cushion. Because we all know that when it comes to stuff that is difficult to find, the price can jump in a hurry if you're competing with a few other collectors to get it.

[t206fanatic]

Originally Posted by Foo3112

I've been using VCP for about 8 years now. Annual subscription cost is $190 I believe.

https://vintagecardprices.com/

am a subscriber as well, excellent site.

[pawpawdiv9]

or use the PSA site, click on auction prices. ITS FREE!

[Ronnie73]

I'm in a similar situation, but I'm trying to find current selling prices, so if something happens to me, what little family I have, has an idea of the going rate. The biggest issue is nearly all my T206's are non Piedmont and Sweet Caporal. I could tell them to just auction them off, and where it ends, it ends. But I'd rather they have the option to offer the cards here on Net54, and the couple facebook groups I'm a part of. I'm planning on scanning all my cards and adding them to a website, where I can update sales on the same card, in different grades, because many of my cards just don't get offered for sale, or they are old prices from years ago, with many that only show what I originally paid 6 plus years ago. Cobbs in a SGC 20 with a Sovereign 150 back, no longer sell for $750. Or cards like a Lundgren Cubs with a EPDG back thats graded SGC 60. How do you find a current sale price on it? Online subscription guides only show common back prices, unless there's something new out there that I don't know about. Plus I'm not just dealing with a couple hundred cards, because then I wouldn't be as concerned, but I'm dealing with 1600+ cards, and that's just for the T206's. I don't have any kids, otherwise I wouldn't be concerned as much. Hopefully we can both get some good advice on value/comps.

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by raulus

Insurance companies will parrot the terms "like kind and quality" to you over and over again. Looks like you have a good photo log of a lot of your pieces, which should help to document the precise items and their quality. Hopefully it's complete.

The gist of the insurance companies' approach is that they will either find replacements that are of similar quality, or they will cut you a check for the amount of your coverage if they can't replace it.

My advice would be to estimate the amount that you would need to pay to replace each item if you had to go out and buy it retail, which is often a lot higher than auction prices. For some stuff, it's not easy to find comps, particularly with raw obscure pieces, just because they're that hard to find, and come onto the market very infrequently. Ebay is certainly a good resource. You can also use cardfinder, which is free, and has the added benefit of including raw cards, although I'm not sure how complete their database is.

In some cases, any given item might not have sold recently, so you'll be relying on old sales data to pick a number. Just make sure to factor in the dramatic runup in prices over the last couple of years.

Ultimately, for some things it might be tough to find much, so you will probably just have to give it your best guess. I would aim a little on the high side, just to give yourself some cushion. Because we all know that when it comes to stuff that is difficult to find, the price can jump in a hurry if you're competing with a few other collectors to get it.

+1 Agree and as others said the VCP site is really good

[rjackson44]

Insurance she watches my safes

[garymc]

Cute dog.........

Isn't there a magazine or a book that I can buy ?

[David W]

There are apps you can purchase, or some of them are even free.

I use Center Stage for my iPhone. It is free.

You simply hold your phone over the card, after two or three seconds, it identifies it, and it gives you the value based on eBay sold sales.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Never mind, missed that it was all prewar.

[JollyElm]

How large is your collection?

I recently created an Excel spreadsheet to list/organize my entire graded card collection (have no idea what to do about ungraded yet, if anything at all). Took forever, because I didn't realize I had so much plastic, but now have the option to (manually) enter/amend 'estimated values' to keep a running tally.

After you find the right method to assess the value of your cards, it might be a workable option for you if the size of your collection doesn't dissuade you from doing so.

Good luck!!

[Gorditadogg]

Originally Posted by pawpawdiv9

or use the PSA site, click on auction prices. ITS FREE!

Yep, I go to psacard.com and check auction prices for my cards. For raw cards, you can also look at their "PSA value," which used to be called SMR value.

I also like the VCP site, because it will automatically update your prices based on reported card sales. I haven't pulled the trigger yet, though, on getting a subscription.



Sent from my SM-S906U using Tapatalk

[Zach Wheat]

Originally Posted by pawpawdiv9

or use the PSA site, click on auction prices. ITS FREE!

Agree with Chris. The PSA app allows you to enter both PSA and non-PSA cards (read "raw"). Auction values (APR Values) as well as PSA's estimate of values are provided for your PSA entries and you can use their raw data to guestimate the raw or other graded card values.

[garymc]

I am about 90% done with a card spreadsheet and I just finished a photo inventory of my Highlander photos. I have photos of the backs but didn't include them in the inventory ? Here are my photo's..........

https://www.flickr.com/photos/151843...77720307100420

[Ronnie73]

Originally Posted by garymc

I am about 90% done with a card spreadsheet and I just finished a photo inventory of my Highlander photos. I have photos of the backs but didn't include them in the inventory ? Here are my photo's..........

https://www.flickr.com/photos/151843...77720307100420

Luckily I built my spreadsheet while I would purchase each card, along with a running total. So I have original purchase dates and prices I paid, along with all the card details. I wish I would have made a location for the seller of the card though.