A favorite non-HOFer....Lefty O'Doul....show us some of his stuff

[tedzan]

In my book, Lefty O'Doul should be in the HOF. Anyhow, I'll start this show with my three 1933 (George C. Miller....DeLong....Goudey) cards.

And, I'll include his 1952 Mother's Cookies card as a tribute to his Manager days in the PCL.


.



..




Pardon my fuzzy scan of the Geo. Miller card's back....my scanner has a problem with SGC graded cards' backs.



TED Z

[Exhibitman]

heh

http://imageevent.com/exhibitman/frankleftyodoulcard

[Kawika]

[calvindog]

[Big Six]

I'm a closet O'Doul collector...


1934 AP Photo

1951 International News Photo

1958 Boston Herald (used for one of his Fleer cards)

[packs]

San Francisco Seals Stamp Album:





Signed line up card from a 1950 game between the Seals and Oaks:

[rhettyeakley]

I agree he should be a HOFer...

[base_ball]

This is probably from the 60s....the place is still in San Francisco, with no connection to O'Doul at this point, I think. Nice bar.

[Runscott]

This is the only thing I have related to O'Doul:

[Big Six]

Originally Posted by Runscott

This is the only thing I have related to O'Doul:

I cursed myself for not bidding on this when it was offered, what, 6 months ago? Great piece...

[dlfallen]

Yeah,I could use a better scanner . . .

[seattlerainiers]

Big fan of Lefty!


Benjamin Franklin Knitting Mills ad card
1939 SF Examiner card
1957 Hygrade Meats card
Carved wooden scrapbook presented to Lefty on Lefty O'Doul Day, 1940, and snapshot of same
Presentation belt buckle from 1934 Tour of Japan

[leftygrove10]

R315

[Ladder7]

Wrong Lefty. Keep it moving.

[h2oya311]

No cards of O'Doul yet in my collection, but just wanted to point out that O'Doul is at least a member of the Japanese HOF!!

[pepis]

He should have never try pitching
it cost him the hall of fame!
if only the Yankees would have noticed!!

[tedzan]

Circa 1928-29 Photo from The Phillies Encyclopedia. Same photo that Goudey used to create their 1933 (Hi #) card of Lefty O'Doul.
.


TED Z

[Mark]

Some lumber:

[prestigecollectibles]

Originally Posted by h2oya311

No cards of O'Doul yet in my collection, but just wanted to point out that O'Doul is at least a member of the Japanese HOF!!

Here is his Japanese HOF plaque.

[tedzan]

TED Z

[tedzan]

Circa 1928-29 Photo from The Phillies Encyclopedia. Same photo that Goudey used to create their 1933 (Hi #) card #232
of Lefty O'Doul. The Phillies traded Lefty to the Dodgers for the 1931 season....citing that they needed pitching. This has
to be one of the dumbest trades in BB history.

Lefty O'Doul's stats during his 2-year tenure with the Phillies. They are very, very impressive. Furthermore, they are the
best in his 11-year career. I guess he liked playing in Philadelphia


Year Age Team G...PA..AB...R....H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO BA..OBP SLG

1929 32 Phillies 154 732 638 152 254 35 6 32 122 76 19 .398 .465 .622

1930 33 Phillies 140 606 528 122 202 37 7 22 097 63 21 .383 .453 .604




TED Z
__________________________________________________ ______________________________________
LOOKING for these 6 - T206 guys to complete my EXCLUSIVE 12 red HINDU sub-set (12 subjects)

DEVORE....FORD....GANDIL....McGRAW (glove)....PFEFFER....SHECKARD (glove)

[MooseDog]

Great thread...I have always held that O'Doul belongs in the Hall of Fame. A travesty really not just for his MLB accomplishments but for what he did to expand the game to Japan and by virtue all of Asia.

I was extremely fortunate to have acquired a number of items from his estate but most of the good stuff was sold off to Dick Dobbins years ago during the many times I ran into financial difficulty. One piece I surely wish I had back was a signed program from the 1934 Goodwill Tour of Japan signed by everyone except Ruth and signed by Gehrig twice. Probably now worth 20x what Dick paid for it, which was a fair price at the time.

The PSA 1936 Zeenut w/coupon that David M. posted was once mine. That one was actually from the estate so it was "Lefty Owned". I sold that when I was new to PSA grading and had been out of the hobby for awhile. Judging by the emails I got after I sold it someone got a heck of a deal at the time.

I also think I have the original photo that was used to make the cover of that scrapbook presented to Lefty. I'd like to find that. I'll post more stuff and help keep this thread alive. Hope it's OK since they aren't cards.

Here is one picture from the estate that I already had scanned. That's O'Doul swinging and even without seeing his face it's pretty obvious who his golf partner is.

[71buc]

Spring Training 1930 Lefty is in the middle

[tedzan]

Originally Posted by MooseDog

Great thread...I have always held that O'Doul belongs in the Hall of Fame. A travesty really not just for his MLB accomplishments but for what he did to expand the game to Japan and by virtue all of Asia.

I was extremely fortunate to have acquired a number of items from his estate but most of the good stuff was sold off to Dick Dobbins years ago during the many times I ran into financial difficulty. One piece I surely wish I had back was a signed program from the 1934 Goodwill Tour of Japan signed by everyone except Ruth and signed by Gehrig twice. Probably now worth 20x what Dick paid for it, which was a fair price at the time.


Here is one picture from the estate that I already had scanned. That's O'Doul swinging and even without seeing his face it's pretty obvious who his golf partner is.

MooseDog

First....Dick Dobbins was one of the greatest guys in this hobby I had the priviledge of knowing.


2nd....DITTO....to what you said regarding Lefty O'Doul not being in the HOF. O'Doul's 11 year career with a .349 lifetime Batting Avg. (4th all-time high BA in the Majors)
certainly qualifies him to be in the HOF.;

Manager (and then hitting instructor) from 1935 - 1961 in the PCL, O'Doul tutored some of the greatest in BB.......Joe and Dom DiMaggio, Ted Williams, Willie Mays, Willie
McCovey, and more.


3rd......might this photo of the Babe be the front view of your photo that day with the Babe and Lefty O'Doul ?






TED Z

[MooseDog]

Ted - they threw the mold away when they made Dobbins. He was truly a "good man" in every sense of the word. Wonderful teacher and collecting mentor.

I think that photo is probably from the same golf outing. There isn't anything on the back of my photo, but here was another, where both Lefty and Babe are wearing the same clothes, in the last Yee auction. If I recall that listing stated the golf outing was either in Hawaii or SF on the way to Japan on one of the Goodwill Tours.

May be hard for some of the younger guys to fathom, but all that talent traveled to Japan on trains and boats. It was a VERY long journey.

[jerrys]

odoul.jpg

[MooseDog]

1921 Zeenut from the O'Doul estate...

[baseballart]

Originally Posted by seattlerainiers

Big fan of Lefty!


Benjamin Franklin Knitting Mills ad card
1939 SF Examiner card
1957 Hygrade Meats card
Carved wooden scrapbook presented to Lefty on Lefty O'Doul Day, 1940, and snapshot of same
Presentation belt buckle from 1934 Tour of Japan

You have the start of quite a nice collection.