Early Data on CSG graded cads

[LACardsGuy]

Looking at completed Feebay auctions on baseball cards. Very few, so this is not a good sample, BUT:

1984 Topps Mattingly CSG 9 sold less than 99.95 (best offer accepted)
VCP says PSA 9 average 127. SGC 60. BGS 51

1958 Maris CSG 3 sold 200
PSA 222. SGC 170. BGS 170

1980 Henderson CSG 7 sold 150
PSA 199. SGC 159. BGS 172.

Clearly, PSA still getting more than the field, but seems like CSG is similar to SGC and BGS so far.

[Gorditadogg]

Interesting, those are solid prices out of the gate.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

[stlcardsfan]

I didn’t think that Henderson was a 7. It looked like there was some dirt on the card in the upper left and the bottom two corners looked a little soft. Jarrod’s Jordan PSA 5 looked much nicer to me.

[stlcardsfan]

I just looked at the Henderson seller’s other items and he has a 1960 Kaline all star graded 5.5 by CSG. Looks to have a lot of surface wear and what may be a large scratch toward the bottom middle of the card? Looks like an issue under the bat on the back of the card also. VG? On my phone can’t link it. EBay seller stmanv_32.