|
New York Giants Notebook
2 Attachment(s)
Has anyone here seen this notebook before - or another from this series?
EDIT: My initial post title said that this was Matty, but I agree with RUKen (thanks for the post) that this looks like Tillie Shafer, who has an interesting story: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tillie_Shafer |
??
Are you sure thats Mathewson?? jus sayin........
|
Matty
That definitely looks like him...
|
Re: Christy Mathewson Notebook - Playing 1st Base
I see a resemblance to Matty, but I'm not 100% convinced. The runner bears a resemblance to Bugs Raymond, which begs the question of why two pitchers would stage a first base scene like that. Interesting piece.
|
Doesn’t scream Matty to me. Face seems way too chubby.
|
Great image
I am not sure it is Matty at first. Looks similar to him, but I agree with Steve N. that the player looks too full faced.
It is definitely 1910 or earlier at Polo Grounds. |
Wierdest part is the throw is coming from off the field.
|
Quote:
|
imho ~
it's Mr "BiG Six" Him Ownself! His face is considerably shaded, why he looks chubby. He is wearing what Mr Mathewson(Uniform) would of worn & No one else actually looks like him, cept maybe Mr Marquad & that ain't him! Mr Mathewson's ears match, as far i can see ~ Who else could he be? it's Mr Mathewson alright!!! :) jmho ! |
Looks like Matty to me, but I wouldn't be shocked to find out it wasn't. Might be Fred Snodgrass sliding in.
|
Quote:
|
4 Attachment(s)
Quote:
|
yep
I think RUKen just solved the mystery.
|
Probably impossible to be sure but the man sliding resembles Larry Doyle
|
I vote not him
1 Attachment(s)
...
|
Like i said... "who else could he be?" :)
Most Excellent Work!!! (i wish it were Matty though!) |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:32 PM. |