Thoughts on this 19th century oddball piece

[aquarius31]

Honestly, thank you very much Matt!!! I went back through your player ids and initially was confused because I only had 2 rows of pictures but then realized that your screen settings may be different. I started with Fulmer and Powell and then went clockwise. I think all the players have been identified now (the guy crouching is Sam Trott) with the exception of the guy in the middle and #2. The smaller external boxes are not something I'm going to look at right now since they are extremely faded with most images being unrecognizable.

At some point, I may have a photographer take several high resolution photos of the display and retouch it to show how it would have looked prior to all the wear and tear. Then I can have a double-sided frame to showcase it.

1) Chris Fulmer and Abner Powell
2) ???
3) John Farrell
4) Chris Fulmer
5) Joseph Tucker
6) Sam Trott
7) Phenomenal Smith
8) Oyster Burns
9) Joe Sommers
10) Matt Kilroy
11) Tom Quinn
12) William Whitaker