Joe Dimaggio---Mickey Mantle Auto Balls Good or Bad

[Big Dave]

Both good.

[GrayGhost]

yes, both good

[shelly]

I am going to take shot here and say that neither one of the balls are authentic. They both look like they came from B and J. The Mantle has the shake and the Joe D is straight up and down.

[thetruthisoutthere]

Ditto!!!!

You could not give me either of those two baseballs.

[Donscards]

Well now I dont know what to do here The first 2 responces said balls were good--the last 2 said no with one responce just taking a chance---any auto experts out there who could give their advice. thanks, Don

[thetruthisoutthere]

Don, why do think they might be good? They are awful. Slowly drawn, lack of spontaneity.

What other experts do you want to opine on those two autographs, Don?

[shelly]

Sorry, I should have said In my opinion both balls are bad. I trust my decision against anyone on here in regards to these two balls. If I am not mistaken I thought I told you why they where not good.

[Donscards]

Well as I stated in my first post---I am not sure if the baseballs are good---the first 2 responces stated the baseballs were good---I would really like to see what Richard Simon states----I feel he is one of the best Auto specialists around----Again I am not postive on the baseballs---I was looking for a resounding yes or no---Right now I have 2 for and 2 against---so I would like a few more responces---thanks for the help both good and bad---if I get more bad---I will agree thanks, Don