Goodwin wins?

[npa589]

If it didnt have a ghost on the front, than the front of the Sweet Cap ghost Bescher would have had to be perfectly cropped and placed in the SGC holder that had the Old Mill flip on there. The two Beschers were identical cards, with different flips and different backs.

Originally Posted by atx840

I'm a bit concerned that the Bescher OM, based on the scans, went that high because bidders thought it has a ghost on the front.

[t206hound]

Originally Posted by npa589

If it didnt have a ghost on the front, than the front of the Sweet Cap ghost Bescher would have had to be perfectly cropped and placed in the SGC holder that had the Old Mill flip on there. The two Beschers were identical cards, with different flips and different backs.

Based on comparisons of the two scans, I'd be EXTREMELY SURPRISED if this wasn't a photoshop job. I see no difference in positioning, corners, colors, etc. between the "two" cards.

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by t206hound

Based on comparisons of the two scans, I'd be EXTREMELY SURPRISED if this wasn't a photoshop job. I see no difference in positioning, corners, colors, etc. between the "two" cards.

I think they just screwed up the descriptions - looked like a text messed-up 'cut and paste' job.

[atx840]

Originally Posted by npa589

If it didnt have a ghost on the front, than the front of the Sweet Cap ghost Bescher would have had to be perfectly cropped and placed in the SGC holder that had the Old Mill flip on there. The two Beschers were identical cards, with different flips and different backs.

I am suspecting they have a clean scan of a T206 SGC slab and add each card & the white block of flip details to this clean scan. The wrong front was used during this process.

I mentioned there was an error when the auction was opened and Bill did reach out to me, I never heard back.

[mrvster]

Congrats to all.....i didn't really bid in this one....Leon, SUPER TUF front miscut in any issue

The Blank Back Chance was ridiculously low imo....WoW...

The hindy Jamie was WAY TOO high(hindus overrated imho)

[bcbgcbrcb]

Anybody pick up the Ruth Big Head Strip Card?

[Matthew H]

Originally Posted by atx840

I am suspecting they have a clean scan of a T206 SGC slab and add each card & the white block of flip details to this clean scan. The wrong front was used during this process.

I mentioned there was an error when the auction was opened and Bill did reach out to me, I never heard back.

That's strange... What would be the point of that? It seems like extra work.