Thoughts on Chief Bender and Earle Combs..

[Runscott]

David, I was just responding to a statement you made, not saying that the autographs are fake.

On the other hand, I wouldn't touch a penciled autograph, regardless of how legit it looked.

[David Atkatz]

I agree one must be careful with team sheets, Scott.

What's wrong with pencil autographs? (It was the writing instrument of choice for kids gathering signatures.)

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by David Atkatz

I agree one must be careful with team sheets, Scott.

What's wrong with pencil autographs? (It was the writing instrument of choice for kids gathering signatures.)

As you know, one must be careful with ANY team items, not just sheets.

Regarding pencil autographs, it doesn't matter to me whether or not children prefer pencils - I want my autographs to be in ink. Again, the disclaimer that I don't disagree that this sheet is legit; however, IF you were going to forge a sheet like this, it would be easier to create a legit-looking forgery using a pencil, as opposed to a fountain pen (assuming we are in pre ballpoint pen era). I would be amazed if anyone disputed this.

Here's is a great thread where many (including yourself) discuss the wonders of lead: http://www.net54baseball.com/showthr...=124499&page=4