What's your Monster number?

[tedzan]

Originally Posted by frankbmd

about Ted's requests. Is a 34 card Monster subset really worthy of a Monster Number or is it some form of Submonster? An accomplishment without doubt but a comparable number to the remainder of the list, I think not.

Hopefully, Ted, you will understand and accept my reasoning here. If you don't, sweetening the pot on our Tinker deal can't hurt.

Frank

I'll try to review the thread to create a list of relevant posts soon.

But Frank....this "Monster" has tentacles....namely, all the silly sub-sets that we can attach to it

Look, this 34-card sub-set (Sweet Cap #649 overprint) is no great accomplishment. But, my American Beauty 460, I consider a "big deal". And, when I complete it,
it is only worth 75 points. Therefore, I will somewhat reluctantly "accept your reasoning" for not adding these "tentacles".

New subject....if I recently broke up one of my "Monsters" and most of it has been sold, do you still accept it ?

If so, I also put together a complete 467-card all SWEET CAPORAL, Factory #30 set (minus Plank & Wagner).


TED Z

[frankbmd]

Originally Posted by tedzan

But Frank....this "Monster" has tentacles....namely, all the silly sub-sets that we can attach to it

Look, this 34-card sub-set (Sweet Cap #649 overprint) is no great accomplishment. But, my American Beauty 460, I consider a "big deal". And, when I complete it,
it is only worth 75 points. Therefore, I will somewhat reluctantly "accept your reasoning" for not adding these "tentacles".

New subject....if I recently broke up one of my "Monsters" and most of it has been sold, do you still accept it ?

If so, I also put together a complete 467-card all SWEET CAPORAL, Factory #30 set (minus Plank & Wagner).


TED Z

Ted, c'mon man. It doesn't matter if a centipede has 96 legs or 104 legs, it's still a centipede. A monster is a monster. If you want to start a tentacle thread or an appendage thread, be my guest. I didn't reject the subsets summarily, I merely don't want the monsters commingled with the tentacles. I'm sure the members enjoy seeing them posted here though.
Obviously if you no longer own a tentacle, it should not be posted, and the appendages you do own should be covered at all times.