The Joe Pelaez T206 Plank

[freakhappy]

Originally Posted by cubsfan-budman

im sure its just the scans, but the staining on the front and back look much lighter in the SGC holder.

I agree...did he dare soak it???

Peter, I was thinking the same thing...it looks more like a VG than Good...nice card.

[Big Six]

Based purely on the scans, that card looks like it was soaked...much brighter appearance in the SGC slab. Or it's just a better scan...thank goodness I'm more of a T205 guy!

[Runscott]

Soaking does not fade the ink on cards. As Scott has mentioned many times, the 350-series Planks are notorious for looking this way - use google.

[Tcards-Please]

Originally Posted by Big Six

Based purely on the scans, that card looks like it was soaked...much brighter appearance in the SGC slab. Or it's just a better scan

I agree that it certainly looks cleaner in the SGC holder and if was soaked, then that means it was submitted as raw. If that was the case, I agree that PSA got it right before soaking and SGC got it right after soaking.

r/
Frank

[Iron Horse]

It looks more like a nice 3 then a 2. SGC got it right. I think PSA does grade tougher in some cases.