Joe McCarthy checks

[Baseball Fan]

Nope. It wasn't in any sort of frame. Just a single check like the one posted.

Is there a way to check past listings on eBay? I'd love to know what I was seeing.

It's obvious I'm an idiot when it comes to these McCarthy checks, though, as I didn't even know they were that difficult and wasn't even willing to go over $100 for one.

Thanks for the response. I take pride in having knowledge of checks like this, but McCarthy went way over my head.

[Baseball Fan]

Just realized I had this in my inbox when I was bidding on the McCarthy check on eBay.


Joe McCarthy signed Autograph 1972 Check Jos. V. McCarthy Auto HOF
Item number: 181032949401
Sale price: $96.00
End time: Dec-02-12 17:30:57 PST

[collectbaseball]

I'm stumped too.

Worthpoint shows six ending on ebay in the last few years for between $40 and $100.

[Baseball Fan]

Originally Posted by collectbaseball

I'm stumped too.

Worthpoint shows six ending on ebay in the last few years for between $40 and $100.

Really?

Haha. Now I'm more confused than ever.

[mr2686]

The PSA price guide lists McCarthy checks at $500. I'm wondering if those that sold on ebay were fake which might account for lack of bidding?

[Baseball Fan]

Originally Posted by mr2686

The PSA price guide lists McCarthy checks at $500. I'm wondering if those that sold on ebay were fake which might account for lack of bidding?

There also is the chance that more checks were released on the market.

[RichardSimon]

Any newer info on McCarthy checks?
Thanks for any help.