PSA cant get it right!!!!

[pclpads]

Originally Posted by sportscollector

I bet BVG grades it a 7.5? or SGC grades it 82 or 84

or PRO: Gem Mint 10?

[Gamebits]

There is a saying in the business world that the third generation will loose the company, either by driving it to the ground or selling it, basically not owning it anymore, I guess the same hold thru for baseball cards.

[RCMcKenzie]

Originally Posted by Gamebits

There is a saying in the business world that the third generation will loose the company, either by driving it to the ground or selling it, basically not owning it anymore, I guess the same hold thru for baseball cards.

I've heard, "Shirtsleeves to shirtsleeves in three generations..."

Nice Cobb card, whatever you decide.

[hammer]

Keep that card its beautiful and PSA is only one man or company's opinion.

[sportscollector]

Originally Posted by pclpads

or PRO: Gem Mint 10?

you mean pro pristine 10 I think pro had a pristine grade before. lol lol

[auggiedoggy]

Originally Posted by pclpads

or PRO: Gem Mint 10?

KSA in Canada also!

[Bridwell]

Another possibility is bleaching. Someone may have touched up the top edge or a small spot with a little clorox. If PSA picked up on it under black light they won't grade.

[CW]

If you are going to attempt the grading angle again, I'd go with SGC over BVG. if you do, it will be interesting to see what they say, and how it grades out. Once graded by SGC, I would most definitely keep it if I were you.

[sportscollector]

Originally Posted by Bridwell

Another possibility is bleaching. Someone may have touched up the top edge or a small spot with a little clorox. If PSA picked up on it under black light they won't grade.

cards never touched any liquid of any type ever.

[leaflover]

Top edge chipping on 1933 Goudeys is common and a sign that they have not been trimmed. Smooth top edges are the ones to be leery of.