Set Consistency

[Harliduck]

Battersbox - I was tired of buying "NM" cards to have them show up with creases...looking at his feedback alone shows buying cards from him is a gamble. I will however say his prices are super cheap for buying raw cards to fill sets. I just wouldn't recommend his grading.

Deans Cards - My wife for Christmas bought some cards off one of my set lists needs. Great cards and she said his customer service was top notch. She hates ebay and liked he took the time to talk to her on the phone, and he even followed up with a call to make sure the cards arrived and were satisfactory. I was really impressed. I finally got the cost out of her and found the price to be above ebay...enough to where me personally wouldn't go there. BUT...I wouldn't discourage any gifts from the wife and it is about service and trust with her, not knowing anything about cards. I really appreciate that.

Just wanted to pass on my .02$


I try and keep my sets in the same raw grade the best I can. I know sets are judged on the stars, so I try and make them the highest grade I can...

[vintagebaseballcardguy]

Originally Posted by Harliduck

Battersbox - I was tired of buying "NM" cards to have them show up with creases...looking at his feedback alone shows buying cards from him is a gamble. I will however say his prices are super cheap for buying raw cards to fill sets. I just wouldn't recommend his grading.

Deans Cards - My wife for Christmas bought some cards off one of my set lists needs. Great cards and she said his customer service was top notch. She hates ebay and liked he took the time to talk to her on the phone, and he even followed up with a call to make sure the cards arrived and were satisfactory. I was really impressed. I finally got the cost out of her and found the price to be above ebay...enough to where me personally wouldn't go there. BUT...I wouldn't discourage any gifts from the wife and it is about service and trust with her, not knowing anything about cards. I really appreciate that.

Just wanted to pass on my .02$


I try and keep my sets in the same raw grade the best I can. I know sets are judged on the stars, so I try and make them the highest grade I can...

I hear you loud and clear on Battersbox. Most of the time, the experience is ok. However, I have landed my share of stinkers. I will say, they are prompt when it comes to refunds. It has been my experience that many of his cards are about a half to a full grade below what he advertises. I had sworn Battersbox off for good but have found myself back looking again lately. Their prices are fairly competitive.

[vintagebaseballcardguy]

I will also add that makes me just want to buy graded cards and be spared the disappointment....

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by vintagebaseballcardguy

I will also add that makes me just want to buy graded cards and be spared the disappointment....

If you're buying raw commons to submit for grading, it's almost always a losing proposition. It's kind of like busting vintage wax looking to make a profit. Sure, you'll get some grades you want, but you'll also get some that leave you scratching your head and very disappointed.

If that is your plan then yes, you are much better off to buy the cards already graded.

[vintagebaseballcardguy]

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

If you're buying raw commons to submit for grading, it's almost always a losing proposition. It's kind of like busting vintage wax looking to make a profit. Sure, you'll get some grades you want, but you'll also get some that leave you scratching your head and very disappointed.

If that is your plan then yes, you are much better off to buy the cards already graded.

I have always been happy to have raw commons and graded stars. There have been some exceptions to this rule, but I generally have followed it.

[Bestdj777]

David, I was being serious. I don't have any affiliation at all with Deans Cards but have been impressed with their selection and prices. I only collect Mantle cards and usually low grade. Their prices seem a lot closer to market than many that I see on ebay (may just be for the lower grade stuff but I assumed they would be fair across the board). Some of their prices are a bit lower than i paid for my cards. Anyway, it is always a good idea to price shop before making a purchase, but in doing so they are worth checking out.

Chris

[vintagebaseballcardguy]

Originally Posted by Harliduck

Battersbox - I was tired of buying "NM" cards to have them show up with creases...looking at his feedback alone shows buying cards from him is a gamble. I will however say his prices are super cheap for buying raw cards to fill sets. I just wouldn't recommend his grading.

Deans Cards - My wife for Christmas bought some cards off one of my set lists needs. Great cards and she said his customer service was top notch. She hates ebay and liked he took the time to talk to her on the phone, and he even followed up with a call to make sure the cards arrived and were satisfactory. I was really impressed. I finally got the cost out of her and found the price to be above ebay...enough to where me personally wouldn't go there. BUT...I wouldn't discourage any gifts from the wife and it is about service and trust with her, not knowing anything about cards. I really appreciate that.

Just wanted to pass on my .02$


I try and keep my sets in the same raw grade the best I can. I know sets are judged on the stars, so I try and make them the highest grade I can...

I have had a little recent experience with Joe's Vintage Sports Cards. So far, what I have purchased and looked at seems to be graded fairly conservatively.