500 HR club autograph opinions needed

[7nohitter]

Wow! Gorgeous!

[Paulanthony]

I have a question. It is my understanding an authentic 500 HR club lithograph is always signed Horizontal not Vertical. I think the mantle is horrible. I can't recall seeing a PSA/JSA certified vertical.

[Paulanthony]

Originally Posted by Paulanthony

I have a question. It is my understanding an authentic 500 HR club lithograph is always signed Horizontal not Vertical. I think the mantle is horrible. I can't recall seeing a PSA/JSA certified vertical.

TomTresh2's channel
For what it's worth 2:43 on the video. Looks the same as op. HE even mentions the Vertical issue.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dUpZFlSxsIY

[mr2686]

Originally Posted by Paulanthony

TomTresh2's channel
For what it's worth 2:43 on the video. Looks the same as op. HE even mentions the Vertical issue.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dUpZFlSxsIY

Well Chris is on here so maybe he'll comment, but looking at the photos these look very good.

[shelly]

They signed every which way. Here is one that is signed totatly different.

500.jpg

[shelly]

Originally Posted by Paulanthony

I have a question. It is my understanding an authentic 500 HR club lithograph is always signed Horizontal not Vertical. I think the mantle is horrible. I can't recall seeing a PSA/JSA certified vertical.

Mantle is perfect.

[Duluth Eskimo]

Originally Posted by Paulanthony

I have a question. It is my understanding an authentic 500 HR club lithograph is always signed Horizontal not Vertical. I think the mantle is horrible. I can't recall seeing a PSA/JSA certified vertical.

I'm really not trying to start something here and I don't believe I know this person posting, but why is this guy commenting?????? This is the same guy who stated the Ted Williams Green Diamond photo was a 1940-50's Ted Williams signature?????????????????? Beyond that this person is referencing PSA / DNA files for 500 HR poster. I am not a PSA / JSA basher and actually quite the contrary, but I would much rather go from my own 25 plus years experience in getting signatures from those guys in person and takes opinions from people that were at that show or in business during those years.

These guys that comment that are completely unfamiliar with the signing habits, appearances, or person tendancies when these guys when they were alive is of little interest or concern to me.

I have had disagreements with Shelly in the past on opinions, but I completely agree that this looks perfect. If this guy is correct and others have an educated opinion that differs from this, I would like to hear specifically why they have problems with any of these signatures.