Help with Roberto Clemente signed mini poster/estate sale find

[GrayGhost]

It looks good to me also

[khw]

not so sure about this one , looks more like the secretarial ones than real ones , that being said i doubt it would pass psa or jsa

[toyman55]

I have one like that and it passed psa opinion but here everyone said it was not good. After much agonizing I had to admit it was bad.

[cubsguy1969]

I'm shocked! A difference of opinion on Net54 over the authenticity of an autograph? That never happens here. Just kidding. I appreciate the input.
But I'm not sure what to do. Like I said, I have only a few bucks in it so if it's not a true Clemente, it's not a huge deal. Disappointing, naturally. But a couple people seem to think it's good. Sigh. That's why I don't typically mess with autographs.

[mr2686]

I'm leaning towards not good. The problem I have is that this style of Clemente is usually more "manic" or hurried. The R in Roberto seems less hurried in your example. As for varying opinions on autographs, you're going to get that when you have an example that has traits that are not "normal.

[mighty bombjack]

Anyone have any authentic "best wishes" inscriptions from Clemente? That seems where the real tell would be.

[mr2686]

Originally Posted by mighty bombjack

Anyone have any authentic "best wishes" inscriptions from Clemente? That seems where the real tell would be.

Here's one. Someone whited out the personalization but you can still see the Best Wishes quite well. This one was purchased from Jim.