BCCG grading question

[ksfarmboy]

Originally Posted by RobertGT

I agree, card should be authentic as Beckett is decent at filtering out fakes and trimmed cards.

But, as I am sure you are aware, with a BCCC 6 you are likely looking at multiple creases or some other major damage on the card. I wouldn't pay more than the equivalent of PSA/SGC 1-2.

Good luck.

I guess I must have gotten the toughest BCCC grader out there. Check these out. There's no creases and no damage on any of them. The Sayers looks so much better in person. The smudges are on my scanner.

[KCRfan1]

Ed, I feel like I owe you and explanation for the answer that I gave to your question. On more than a couple of times I have seen cards graded by BCCG that had been trimmed. Rather than grading the cards with an " A ", the cards recieved a numerical grade. Personally, I am not comfortable with them as a grading company. Just my opinion though.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by KCRfan1

Ed, I feel like I owe you and explanation for the answer that I gave to your question. On more than a couple of times I have seen cards graded by BCCG that had been trimmed. Rather than grading the cards with an " A ", the cards recieved a numerical grade. Personally, I am not comfortable with them as a grading company. Just my opinion though.

It is not just BCCG that you have to watch for trimmed cards. BVG & BGS are just as bad for this problem.

[KCRfan1]

Originally Posted by bnorth

It is not just BCCG that you have to watch for trimmed cards. BVG & BGS are just as bad for this problem.

You're right. There is a 1973 Munson graded by BVG that is trimmed on the sides for sale on ebay right now.

[gs1833]

With bccg, look at the condition grade name, rather than the number. This Bradshaw is a "6 - good" which makes it roughly comparable to a psa/bvg 2 (good) rather than a psa/bgs 6.

[RobertGT]

Originally Posted by ksfarmboy

I guess I must have gotten the toughest BCCC grader out there. Check these out. There's no creases and no damage on any of them. The Sayers looks so much better in person. The smudges are on my scanner.

Clint,
You are confusing BCCG with BVG (which are the cards you posted). They are NOT the same. BVG and BGS are pretty comparable grade-wise to PSA and SGC. BCCG, uh, just looks like this:

Ebay seller actually wants $83 for the above card, by the way.
This is a perfect example of why this whole BGS-BVG-BCCG mess is just a nightmare for the hobby.

[ksfarmboy]

Originally Posted by RobertGT

Clint,
You are confusing BCCG with BVG (which are the cards you posted). They are NOT the same. BVG and BGS are pretty comparable grade-wise to PSA and SGC. BCCG, uh, just looks like this:

Ebay seller actually wants $83 for the above card, by the way.
This is a perfect example of why this whole BGS-BVG-BCCG mess is just a
nightmare for the hobby.

I guess I was. I thought they were all the same. You can tell I don't get things graded. These and a handful of others are the only ones I've ever sent in. That Bradshaw looks horrible.