14 Cady

[Theo_450]

Originally Posted by btkpath

Thanks Ted……Yes, I do have a Pratt, but it is only a PSA 1 (see below)

That is an awesome 1! Does the back have issues, or did the slight registration issues keep it from grading higher? A couple great looking cards there!

[btkpath]

Originally Posted by Theo_450

That is an awesome 1! Does the back have issues

Thanks and great question Ted! Here's the answer…..

[ajjohnsonsoxfan]

Man that's a tough "1". I bet you get a two if you had it reviewed.

[ajjohnsonsoxfan]

Originally Posted by btkpath

Thanks and great question Ted! Here's the answer…..

It's really nuts the variations in the grades. check out this psa2 compared to your 1

[Theo_450]

Whoa! Maybe we don't see something in the scans that the grader did, but that is worthy of liberating and resubmitting, and if it comes back as a 1 again, I would crack it out again and submit to SGC. I no longer own this card (auctioned it off last summer), but I must have caught the grader on a real good day. It appears to have the same registration issues as your card does. Note the shift of the grass to the right.

[btkpath]

Hey Ted, any 1914 Pratt is a beautiful card, although I guess I am a bit irked that these are the only two PSA 1 1914 Cracker Jack Pratts…..

[ajjohnsonsoxfan]

Barry you got F'd on that grade! Resubmit

[usernamealreadytaken]

I have found PSA really deducts for the surface "wrinkles" on 14CJs (like your Pratt). I have a couple that present like 3s or better but are PSA 1s or 1.5s