Need some help finding a Jackie Robinson card

[brian1961]

Howdy BIGMARCCL,

What you are undertaking is a very, very thoughtful gift idea. May I simply say that the 1956 Topps that others have shown would definitely be the best choice, economically and from the key standpoint of being one of Jack's most visually stunning cards.

Now, whether graded or not. I would buy a professionally graded card, either from PSA or SGC. There's something about the sturdiness, safety, security, and beauty of an old baseball card in a graded card holder. You can handle it and won't have to worry if your Grandfather holds it! It's well worth the extra cost. If you could possibly see your way to purchase a card that's EXCELLENT or better, that would greatly increase the chances of it appreciating in value. Look for one where the picture registry looks very clear and defined. Compare several cards on eBay and you'll know what I mean. Especially on Jackie's face.

Unfortunately, obviously, the better the graded card, the higher the cost. There are some Very Goods and Very Good - Excellents that are strictly graded and look splendid. After all, price counts. Unless, you could save up a few months longer and make it a combo of birthday and Christmas or Chanukah---and give it to him at the end of the year, while for now breathe a few words of "something's comin', something good". The sweet anticipation will be special.

These are just ideas. Do as you wish. I'm sure he'll be thrilled to get a genuine Jackie Robinson baseball card. But I strongly agree with the others; buy a professionally graded specimen from either PSA or SGC. Also, if you saw one you really liked on Dean's Cards, make him an offer. A 56 Topps Robinson is a common card, but uncommonly gorgeous. He wants to sell. But, he doesn't want to "give a high demand card away". To buy that card on the cheap, you'll probably have to settle for a lesser grade with as good of eye appeal as you can find. Ponder the matter in your heart, and feel free to ask us more questions, etc. We're on your side, buddy.

Wishing you the very best in this gift quest. Take care. --Brian Powell

[CharleyBrown]

I definitely concur with the recommendation for a 1956 card.

Awesome gift idea!!

[Bigmarccl]

Originally Posted by brian1961

Howdy BIGMARCCL,

What you are undertaking is a very, very thoughtful gift idea. May I simply say that the 1956 Topps that others have shown would definitely be the best choice, economically and from the key standpoint of being one of Jack's most visually stunning cards.

Now, whether graded or not. I would buy a professionally graded card, either from PSA or SGC. There's something about the sturdiness, safety, security, and beauty of an old baseball card in a graded card holder. You can handle it and won't have to worry if your Grandfather holds it! It's well worth the extra cost. If you could possibly see your way to purchase a card that's EXCELLENT or better, that would greatly increase the chances of it appreciating in value. Look for one where the picture registry looks very clear and defined. Compare several cards on eBay and you'll know what I mean. Especially on Jackie's face.

Unfortunately, obviously, the better the graded card, the higher the cost. There are some Very Goods and Very Good - Excellents that are strictly graded and look splendid. After all, price counts. Unless, you could save up a few months longer and make it a combo of birthday and Christmas or Chanukah---and give it to him at the end of the year, while for now breathe a few words of "something's comin', something good". The sweet anticipation will be special.

These are just ideas. Do as you wish. I'm sure he'll be thrilled to get a genuine Jackie Robinson baseball card. But I strongly agree with the others; buy a professionally graded specimen from either PSA or SGC. Also, if you saw one you really liked on Dean's Cards, make him an offer. A 56 Topps Robinson is a common card, but uncommonly gorgeous. He wants to sell. But, he doesn't want to "give a high demand card away". To buy that card on the cheap, you'll probably have to settle for a lesser grade with as good of eye appeal as you can find. Ponder the matter in your heart, and feel free to ask us more questions, etc. We're on your side, buddy.

Wishing you the very best in this gift quest. Take care. --Brian Powell

Thank you very much for the detailed response and suggestions. Everyone here has been really cool about helping me out. I wouldn't mind spending a little more but my wife isn't really thrilled with the idea. I can maybe ask her how she feels about combining gifts and seeing if we can do better. He has told me in the past how much he wants a JR card and I'm very excited to find one for him. I know he will love it. Is my best bet EBAY? I would like to thank everyone for their help.