How could PSA make a mistake like this on a Babe Ruth Exhibit Card??????

[MattyC]

More proof that the "professional" graders can get it very, very wrong. Passionate collectors' eyes trump the TPGs time and again. Too often the TPGs and their subjective opinions are put on a pedestal.

[Buythatcard]

I didn't know the difference until I just did some research. I've attached a copy of the real deal. Two things you will notice is that the caption on the bottom is different and the bottom border below the bats has two lines on the real card and the reprint has one. The pillars are also different.

[whiteymet]

I contacted the seller to tell him he had a repro card in the PSA holder.

Never heard back from him.

Looks like the card sold for $700!!!

Someone got taken. And now with ebay hiding bidders/winners "handle" no way to contact the buyer to let him know.

Sad.

Guess I should have bought it and made PSA pay the difference!

[Leon]

That is a shame. I dare anyone to post this on the CU board .

[edjs]

Just a thought on this, I don't know if it could be done or not, but is there a chance that a real card was submitted and graded, then the fake swapped out in the holder and sold?

[Pat R]

...

[whiteymet]

Originally Posted by Leon

That is a shame. I dare anyone to post this on the CU board .

Leon:

Since I am not a graded guy or on CU what are the "politics" involved?

What would happen if someone did post this on CU? I am curious.

Fred

[sbfinley]

Originally Posted by whiteymet

Leon:

Since I am not a graded guy or on CU what are the "politics" involved?

What would happen if someone did post this on CU? I am curious.

Fred

In before the poof. Be careful what you say.... big daddy is listening.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by whiteymet

Leon:

Since I am not a graded guy or on CU what are the "politics" involved?

What would happen if someone did post this on CU? I am curious.

Fred

See Sbfinley's response above. IF anyone on that board brings up something that is derogatory or shows something PSA did wrong, it gets deleted. That fact, and the fact they let trolls on their board, led me to no longer participate there. There are some good guys on that board, of course, but the way it is run isn't something I want to be a part of. To each their own and I am sure some folks say that about this place too . If I am not mistaking, even mentioning this board over there will get a thread deleted. Happy collecting...

[PowderedH2O]

Leon speaks the truth. I have seen threads that were several years old with literally hundreds (or thousands) of messages get completely deleted because a person made a slam against PSA or questioned their integrity. I still use the board, but not nearly as much as I did several years ago.

Perhaps this sort of mistake is why PSA still won't grade the football exhibits. Maybe they really don't have anyone that can legitimately tell the difference between real, fake, and reprint on these.