Trimmed E cards - Do they need to be graded before selling?

[steve B]

I think it depends on where you want to sell them. BST - probably not worth grading any of them. Auction house- also probably not unless the auction wants to do it. Ebay - The Hofers for sure, and maybe a couple others if it's an uncommon set. I think either SGC or PSA would give them an A, and then it's just a matter of which you prefer.

Steve B

[camlov2]

Thanks for the replies.
I have been in contact with PSA and they have told me they won't be able to slab these cards as Authentic/Trimmed. I guess I will try SGC next. Interesting decision by PSA, they are the only grading company I have ever used and now this decision pushes me to try another TPG.

[jbsports33]

Try and get SGC to grade just the Matty and Wagner - talk with Sean

good luck

jimmy

[Fred]

Agree with Bob, the Mathewson and Wagner might we worth slabbing.

[4815162342]

Originally Posted by camlov2

Thanks for the replies.

I have been in contact with PSA and they have told me they won't be able to slab these cards as Authentic/Trimmed. I guess I will try SGC next. Interesting decision by PSA, they are the only grading company I have ever used and now this decision pushes me to try another TPG.

Did they give you a reason why?

[camlov2]

their response-
"After speaking with the Grading Department, unfortunately, these are not cards that we would place in an Authentic (Altered) holder. If these cards were submitted to PSA for authentication and grading, they would simply be sent back as N5-Altered Stock."