Problem with Legendary Lot . . . Opinions?

[jhs5120]

Now that I have finished reading..

I agree with Leon, they are only guilty of small scans.

If I am buying a group of cards that are in PSA/SGC 1 (I used to buy bulk t206 cards in low grade back in the day). I generally expect every single card to be mangled and I bid accordingly.

By SGC's grading criteria, a "1" designation is in "poor" condition. You received cards that were in poor condition. You shouldn't have expected anything better.

On a side note, if this happened to me and it legitimately upset me I would have asked for a $50 refund, not $260. $260 seems like you are trying to pull a fast one on them. The cards aren't worth $260 less because they are a low end 1 instead of a high end 1. They are worth virtually the same.

Why did you expect they would offer you the buyers AND sellers premium back?

[vargha]

Originally Posted by Rich Klein

David:

That is a perfect chance to post those scans and let us see the visual evidence.

Rich

The scanner doesn't work on the new computer. I need to move it over to another computer and get this done. Sorry for being a flake about this.

[vargha]

Originally Posted by jhs5120

Now that I have finished reading..

I agree with Leon, they are only guilty of small scans.

If I am buying a group of cards that are in PSA/SGC 1 (I used to buy bulk t206 cards in low grade back in the day). I generally expect every single card to be mangled and I bid accordingly.

By SGC's grading criteria, a "1" designation is in "poor" condition. You received cards that were in poor condition. You shouldn't have expected anything better.

On a side note, if this happened to me and it legitimately upset me I would have asked for a $50 refund, not $260. $260 seems like you are trying to pull a fast one on them. The cards aren't worth $260 less because they are a low end 1 instead of a high end 1. They are worth virtually the same.

Why did you expect they would offer you the buyers AND sellers premium back?

I didn't "expect" anything, which is good, because I received nothing. I asked for them to take the lot back, but I would have at least grudgingly "settled" for them refunding my buyer's premium.

And your assertion that "They are worth virtually the same" is just silliness. I have two people on this board who made offers on the Alexanders. Should I anonymously contact them back and see if they agree with you?

[Rich Klein]

Inquiring Minds Wants to Know

I was reminded of this thread by the Dean's Card thread

[tiger8mush]

Originally Posted by Rich Klein

What was the conclusion to this exciting thread?

we're still waiting for scans, due by noon