Opinions on my '56 Mick...

[cammb]

You didn't doctor anything. You removed something on the card that wasnt put there to begin with. Second of all, if you want a true grading of your cards, then SGC is the company. PSA is a joke with their grading.

[jchcollins]

Originally Posted by cammb

You didn't doctor anything. You removed something on the card that wasnt put there to begin with. Second of all, if you want a true grading of your cards, then SGC is the company. PSA is a joke with their grading.

I like the way you think. PSA and SGC aside (I like SGC better too...) I have my own grading standards that I've been comfortable with for years. I may be in the minority but I actually think it's fun to grade cards and be able to explain why a card is a certain grade.

[nebboy]

Im showing my 56 Mantle with the same corner chipping problems but my was from being in a screw down holder that was to tight or so I was told by the guy I bought it from. Its has never been graded because Im not getting rid of it. I have been told in a past thread that PSA would be the company to sent it to for the would be more forgiving on the corner chipping or SGC. My best guess is that both of are cards would grade a 3. All of this has been brought up in this tread already but its maybe help to others to know how fragile the corner can be on the 56 set.

[KCRfan1]

Nice card John.